Org Mobile Site
Thread: Tarot Mafia
That was meant to start at 1.32 stupid org
Originally Posted by nebjiamn:
stett does not like being called didi but otherwise yes
stett does not like being called didi but otherwise yes
also I know i've been playing fast and loose with pronouns this game; I get someone's wrong and it bothers you, feel free to prod me, I usually only need to be told once
Originally Posted by grr:
I can't help but wonder if that is like a preemptive statement to keep benneh in PoE this time while discouraging being wolfread for it.
I also don't know why you shrug off Maples d1 posts as NAI on principle so quickly. Is that something you truely believe like can you explain what you think is gonna happen or change later on with regards to his alignment? I mean he is an avid shitposter but he made a read already so I feel like we might not be going into a unreadable-trajectory here?
It's not but I can see what you mean. It's just that I can't force read people, it's not just Benneh (I pretty much have the same approach to Insomnia). I'll get there when I get there, pretty much. It's not as much of a "I won't try to read you" as "I don't really have a read on you yet and I don't really expect me to learn how to find you in this game".I can't help but wonder if that is like a preemptive statement to keep benneh in PoE this time while discouraging being wolfread for it.
I also don't know why you shrug off Maples d1 posts as NAI on principle so quickly. Is that something you truely believe like can you explain what you think is gonna happen or change later on with regards to his alignment? I mean he is an avid shitposter but he made a read already so I feel like we might not be going into a unreadable-trajectory here?
"Truly believe" depends on how literal you wanna be. I think everyone's always doing AI stuff all the time and the game is about finding and understanding that on both a micro point and a macro point. But I have never been able to read Maple early on. I caught him once but it was for the wrong reasons (I was new and thought shit posting was wolfy and he just happened to wolf), then follow up with misreading him 5+ times after that so I'm just gonna wait until there's more information to work with - He's a wolf strategist and I think that my best chances of finding him is through that mindset. He was easy to interact with earlier, but it wasn't game related, so most likely NAI.
Originally Posted by Syn:
town:
newcomb
maple
dyachei
gemma
idk fine i guess:
nebjiamn
didistetter
sunbae
grr
insomnia
c0balt
i can't recall a single post/no opinion:
arctic
vanta black
theknightsofneeee
why (diet version):
enderwiggin
colonellubriderm
why:
raskolnikov
wisdom
jan
sheepsaysmeep
are hally and montmorency actually playing this game or are they in the player list for the lulz
what a wild ass list, like not in a bad way like in breath of fresh air waytown:
newcomb
maple
dyachei
gemma
idk fine i guess:
nebjiamn
didistetter
sunbae
grr
insomnia
c0balt
i can't recall a single post/no opinion:
arctic
vanta black
theknightsofneeee
why (diet version):
enderwiggin
colonellubriderm
why:
raskolnikov
wisdom
jan
sheepsaysmeep
are hally and montmorency actually playing this game or are they in the player list for the lulz
top town excluding me are 3 people who are super super periphery
ladd is straight up missing
sheep unsorted and question marked when sheep is kind of like a pivot point this game IMO
honestly I vibe with it
I don't agree with it at all but just from the way it's structured it really feels like a villager made it
want to hear more ofc but it strikes me as a tough post for a wolf to make and not seem calculated or motivated
oh shit ladd lmao they go in idk fine I guess
maybe I should hate them for wanting to shoot me though
maybe I should hate them for wanting to shoot me though
looks at my poe
looks at this post
looks at my poe
looks at this post
surely it cannot be
looks at this post
looks at my poe
looks at this post
surely it cannot be
Originally Posted by insomnia:
im only playing this way cuz i don't wanna get lunched d1, but im probably gonna vote completely different people to the ones i posted thoughts on. really they're here just for me to get villa read
felt like if i played normally, you guys would d1 me
earlier i said i could vote cobalt because of his sheep read, but it's really a lacking vote in spice levels and i also don't think he was posting egregiously or anything. i'll chill out now that you've all fell for my strat
probably the realest feeling in the thread so farim only playing this way cuz i don't wanna get lunched d1, but im probably gonna vote completely different people to the ones i posted thoughts on. really they're here just for me to get villa read
felt like if i played normally, you guys would d1 me
earlier i said i could vote cobalt because of his sheep read, but it's really a lacking vote in spice levels and i also don't think he was posting egregiously or anything. i'll chill out now that you've all fell for my strat
Spoiler Alert, click show to read:
@nebjamin wait til you find out montemorency is a montecore alt
Originally Posted by ColonelLubriderm:
@nebjamin wait til you find out montemorency is a montecore alt
@nebjiamn@nebjamin wait til you find out montemorency is a montecore alt
ladd congratulated 0 people for their rand btw. pretty sus iyam.
Originally Posted by didistetter:
@Jan see, the problem for me is i kinda associate that more with his townplay than wolfplay, which means the early eagerness here kinda feels in line with what i'd expect from w!balt
#160 just feels hedgey to me, but intentionally so. i kinda doubt thats a post either v!cobalt or w!cobalt would anticipate getting heat for, so idrk if i buy your analysis, but. i'll keep it in mind, ty
Not a read I am married to. I very much changed the read while I made the initial post.@Jan see, the problem for me is i kinda associate that more with his townplay than wolfplay, which means the early eagerness here kinda feels in line with what i'd expect from w!balt
#160 just feels hedgey to me, but intentionally so. i kinda doubt thats a post either v!cobalt or w!cobalt would anticipate getting heat for, so idrk if i buy your analysis, but. i'll keep it in mind, ty
Originally Posted by didistetter:
@Jan gemma has the vibes of a badger that got woken up by birds at 3am and is now drinking tea to cope.
translation: they have a kinda bruskness and "im too cool for this" attitude, which like, *can* be a way for maf to slank and blend, but i typically associate with villies. i also vibe with their lil micro comments like:
#138, #266, and how they've used basic "why" pokes.
this might seem a bit odd of a q, but: if you had to hypothetically assign one person in thread The Hermit card, who would you reckon best fits the bill?
I actually love this question. loaded tbh.@Jan gemma has the vibes of a badger that got woken up by birds at 3am and is now drinking tea to cope.
translation: they have a kinda bruskness and "im too cool for this" attitude, which like, *can* be a way for maf to slank and blend, but i typically associate with villies. i also vibe with their lil micro comments like:
#138, #266, and how they've used basic "why" pokes.
this might seem a bit odd of a q, but: if you had to hypothetically assign one person in thread The Hermit card, who would you reckon best fits the bill?
I am trying to look for someone that fits
Spoiler Alert, click show to read:
dyachei
nebjiamn
Gemma
ColonelLubriderm
Theknightsofneeee
Is what I am left with.
Hard to pick a single person tbh.
I will pick Bop! Out of all of them he can roleplay hermit the best!
mason goes a bit far, but we can dance and see where it leads us.
no slow dancing for now.
and please change your attire first. you spilled some brown liquid on it and I am not sure if I want to associate with that.
no slow dancing for now.
and please change your attire first. you spilled some brown liquid on it and I am not sure if I want to associate with that.
Tiers of citizens(not sorted within)
Tier 1
Didistetter
Newcomb
Wisdom
Tier 2
Syn
insomnia
Arctic
Tier 3
EnderWiggin
Ladd
grr
Slums
Raskolnikov
C0balt
people I should have a read on but I simply don't
dyachei
Sunbae
people I should not have a read on and I don't
Vanta Black
nebjiamn
Gemma
ColonelLubriderm
Maple
Montmorency
Theknightsofneeee
sheepsaysmeep
I don't have a good wolfread right now. But I feel good about ~half of the game!
That is close to a winning poe, maybe!
Tier 1
Didistetter
Newcomb
Wisdom
Tier 2
Syn
insomnia
Arctic
Tier 3
EnderWiggin
Ladd
grr
Slums
Raskolnikov
C0balt
people I should have a read on but I simply don't
dyachei
Sunbae
people I should not have a read on and I don't
Vanta Black
nebjiamn
Gemma
ColonelLubriderm
Maple
Montmorency
Theknightsofneeee
sheepsaysmeep
I don't have a good wolfread right now. But I feel good about ~half of the game!
That is close to a winning poe, maybe!
Technically knights and sheep do not belong in the bottom tier.
I just don't want to read back and in my head I have both of them as gth villa that has done wolfshaped stuff.
And that normally is the tier where I am wrong on and should never made the read in the first place.
So fuck them for now.
And not reading back because lazy.
I just don't want to read back and in my head I have both of them as gth villa that has done wolfshaped stuff.
And that normally is the tier where I am wrong on and should never made the read in the first place.
So fuck them for now.
And not reading back because lazy.
tier 3 is lame i wanna be like. tier1+ or wolfread. tier 3 is kinda like where people tolerate ur existence but kinda keep taking potshots at you and you already know you're never gonna be nightkilled and it's so cringe.
Originally Posted by Jan:
I will pick Bop! Out of all of them he can roleplay hermit the best!
i feel both seen and cut at the same timeI will pick Bop! Out of all of them he can roleplay hermit the best!
wolves are usually the people you have no read on. like. they kinda sound nice and you wanna give them a townlean becuz it feels like you should but something is missing that makes you really convinced.
Originally Posted by grr:
tier 3 is lame i wanna be like. tier1+ or wolfread. tier 3 is kinda like where people tolerate ur existence but kinda keep taking potshots at you and you already know you're never gonna be nightkilled and it's so cringe.
You are not in the slums! tier 3 is lame i wanna be like. tier1+ or wolfread. tier 3 is kinda like where people tolerate ur existence but kinda keep taking potshots at you and you already know you're never gonna be nightkilled and it's so cringe.
You can dream of leaving your work in the mines for an underpaid desk-job one day!
You can maybe marry one of the tier 2 people if they feel lonely.
Tier 1 is not impossible but I would need to read your posts for that. Not sure if that will happen any time soon.
Originally Posted by Newcomb:
what a wild ass list, like not in a bad way like in breath of fresh air way
top town excluding me are 3 people who are super super periphery
ladd is straight up missing
sheep unsorted and question marked when sheep is kind of like a pivot point this game IMO
honestly I vibe with it
I don't agree with it at all but just from the way it's structured it really feels like a villager made it
want to hear more ofc but it strikes me as a tough post for a wolf to make and not seem calculated or motivated
Thing being its prolly a copypasta from Benneh in wc.what a wild ass list, like not in a bad way like in breath of fresh air way
top town excluding me are 3 people who are super super periphery
ladd is straight up missing
sheep unsorted and question marked when sheep is kind of like a pivot point this game IMO
honestly I vibe with it
I don't agree with it at all but just from the way it's structured it really feels like a villager made it
want to hear more ofc but it strikes me as a tough post for a wolf to make and not seem calculated or motivated
Switching to comp, Wisdom I am replying to u about Syn in a few
Originally Posted by grr:
tier 3 is lame i wanna be like. tier1+ or wolfread. tier 3 is kinda like where people tolerate ur existence but kinda keep taking potshots at you and you already know you're never gonna be nightkilled and it's so cringe.
Sucks to be Ladd lmaotier 3 is lame i wanna be like. tier1+ or wolfread. tier 3 is kinda like where people tolerate ur existence but kinda keep taking potshots at you and you already know you're never gonna be nightkilled and it's so cringe.
Originally Posted by Newcomb:
good lord
Okay you're not the only one doing it i'm not talking to just you here, and high chance I come off as old man yelling at clouds, but goddamn some of you need to activate the editor brain and not just the writer brain.
I'm all for stream of consciousness and i'm a big advocate that making your thoughts clear and your process transparent is a great thing to do in mafia games, but good lord.
Some of y'all are giving multiple paragraphs to thoughts that are really not complex enough to warrant it
again, to be clear, not talking directly to you, there are a couple lyrical miracle posters ITT.
It might just be a me thing, but I find it easier to hide in the absurdity that is stream-of-consciousness posting. You can use a lot of words to say very little and actually seem like you're putting in effort. More or less the basis of my wolf game.good lord
Okay you're not the only one doing it i'm not talking to just you here, and high chance I come off as old man yelling at clouds, but goddamn some of you need to activate the editor brain and not just the writer brain.
I'm all for stream of consciousness and i'm a big advocate that making your thoughts clear and your process transparent is a great thing to do in mafia games, but good lord.
Some of y'all are giving multiple paragraphs to thoughts that are really not complex enough to warrant it
again, to be clear, not talking directly to you, there are a couple lyrical miracle posters ITT.
In that way, I always react poorly to meandering posts.
Guess IH played with IAWY :p
Originally Posted by grr:
wolves are usually the people you have no read on. like. they kinda sound nice and you wanna give them a townlean becuz it feels like you should but something is missing that makes you really convinced.
damn, ig jan, colonel, and dya are wolves thenwolves are usually the people you have no read on. like. they kinda sound nice and you wanna give them a townlean becuz it feels like you should but something is missing that makes you really convinced.
Sup stet, any thoughts on Benneh's blatant attempt to pocket you?
Originally Posted by Wisdom:
Why does everyone say "Let it cook/Simmer" and "I'll leave the game to the pros"??
Fam everyone is a champ in this game, no one has over 30 posts, we need more content, throw out more half-baked reads tbh! :3 It's okay to be wrong d1!
@WisdomWhy does everyone say "Let it cook/Simmer" and "I'll leave the game to the pros"??
Fam everyone is a champ in this game, no one has over 30 posts, we need more content, throw out more half-baked reads tbh! :3 It's okay to be wrong d1!
ik this is meant to be a hypeing people of post, but something doesnt quite sit right.
where do you see the bolded mentality at all? that kinda just feels like you conjured it up imo.
let it cook is a valid approach—and you say as much yourself. people need time and space to post more and develope reads
idk it kinda feels like you're being prickly over nothing here?
Originally Posted by didistetter:
damn, ig jan, colonel, and dya are wolves then
by that metric i could see jan in your list. not so much the others but i literally forgot what read i had on colonel before.damn, ig jan, colonel, and dya are wolves then
Originally Posted by Raskolnikov:
Sup stet, any thoughts on Benneh's blatant attempt to pocket you?
:PSup stet, any thoughts on Benneh's blatant attempt to pocket you?
i'm voting him!
Originally Posted by Maple:
It might just be a me thing, but I find it easier to hide in the absurdity that is stream-of-consciousness posting. You can use a lot of words to say very little and actually seem like you're putting in effort. More or less the basis of my wolf game.
In that way, I always react poorly to meandering posts.
Yeah its criminally nai for arctic he just does it as both alignments.It might just be a me thing, but I find it easier to hide in the absurdity that is stream-of-consciousness posting. You can use a lot of words to say very little and actually seem like you're putting in effort. More or less the basis of my wolf game.
In that way, I always react poorly to meandering posts.
Originally Posted by grr:
wolves are usually the people you have no read on. like. they kinda sound nice and you wanna give them a townlean becuz it feels like you should but something is missing that makes you really convinced.
Therefore...wolves are usually the people you have no read on. like. they kinda sound nice and you wanna give them a townlean becuz it feels like you should but something is missing that makes you really convinced.
Single Sign On provided by vBSSO