what does "convincing" mean here? even though people yelled at me, i made it pretty clear why i needed to see visor flip
the fact that he flipped w was pure luck
and then we lost an extra villager in the night, and we have to rely on a third party to relay the check on cuth, which... i don't love. right now i think everyone has reasons to be townread so hard choices are coming
i mean that your vote was purely mechanical, not voting visor cuz you thought he was a wolf
which is a fine way to choose your vote at EoD tbc, but even prior to that i don’t really remember you wolf reading anyone
i wouldn’t worry about ladd lying about cuth being clear, they would have to be exactly w/w so not worth thinking about unless cuth is alive in lylo
though i do think it’s bit strange that rask would choose to shoot cuth over wisdom, who i think he wolf read more
unvote
vote: ender
-
rip me for not actually reading this post earlier. this is EXACTLY what was going through my head this very minute. and then i saw ender's answer and it didn't really do anything for me
this is kind of dodging the original question
you said:
so pretend we're in that moment. you flip rask and he's v. what would that have told you at the time? a bunch of what? if you say "that visor's a wolf the end" i will slap you silly
That Visor is a wolf, the end.
Nah Rask state tells me nothing about Visor. I think Rask green makes me even more sus of Wisdom for the interaction/read there. Which is why I'm pushing Wisdom atm.
I even straight up said this on D1 but I guess people didn't read that.
I also think it makes Syn very likely town. I already thought this but it reinforces it.
I thought it would make Cuth more sus but that's irrelevant for now.
And at the time I was like "If Rask is green then Ladd probably green just from the way posted at/around each other." but idk how much I believe in that read anymore.
I'm ngl it's actually really annoying that I was the first to push a sus on Visor and I'm now in this situation where people are voting me and putting forward me being a wolf.
Most people at the time when I first voiced it (though I was acting my bit at the time and being silly so not really trying to convince others yet) were like "Visor is fine" or "Visor is town". He was on a few POEs but no one really put any sus on him specifically
I think... Waza was the next person to voice anything on it? And that was pages after my initial sus. And then Wisdom Ruleof3's Visor a bunch but never goes there. I don't really remember anyone else following onto Visor until he made the weird-ass post on me.
Like at what point does an experienced player look at thread, see that they're voted by like 2 people(1 of which is a partner who has no reason to stick the vote there permanently) and vaguely sussed by a few others, and say "I'm gonna make a weird-ass toneswitch read on my partner, that'll do it."
i think his responses to my grilling at eod look generally good given the results
on visor's role, he was pretty doa so unless wolves chose not to go for a snipe due to the wagon formations, i'd say he just sorta died without the opportunity to use it; i think in general wolves have a pretty strong d1 given visor was *sort of* a dv
also vanillaizor tells us... basically nothing, tho the inventor mode is kinda interesting i guess
Bookmarks