Ok, I'm on a bus for next 14 hours. That means I have time to read and post. Also, I'm on my phone and this site is 't phone friendly. I'm going to reread the thread first and maybe react to some comments. Don't expect walls of quotes from me. I also find the arctic's return spicy, because that player isn't towny IMHO. I wouldn't mind taffy/arctic wagons rn, but returning to taffy's posts first might be a good idea.
Some other initial thoughts. I like Bennet's posts more than waza's now. In some of them I could spot what seemed to be a genuine thought process. I quite like Lissa and Day now. I have the slightest townlean on Ender for their posts being blunt. It's like Ender doesn't really care about getting wolfread. Stett doesn't feel so good to me, but I'm willing to sheep Ladd on them for now. I'm also intrigued by sunbae wolf leans.