Gemma's Favorite Music Mafia

[ladd]

Maybe this is another stett is bad and wrong and needs to stfu like a good girl moment but... Realistically i see a world that's three town.

Ok so who are the wolves then? Without including me ofc

Pick a person thats not.me and ill close my eyes and vote with you if u want. Genuinely

I gave a poe of lissa/maple/ender. I guess you think benneh could be a wolf outside of that PoE or is there other people too?

[didistetter]

Ok so who are the wolves then? Without including me ofc

Pick a person thats not.me and ill close my eyes and vote with you if u want. Genuinely

I gave a poe of lissa/maple/ender. I guess you think benneh could be a wolf outside of that PoE or is there other people too?

Vote: Lissa

[Maple]

*towns about*

idk yall the shit people are saying about my slot actually boggles my mind, idt anyone is really engaging with what ive said in a productive way but at the same time i havent engaged with the game nearly enough to have a body of work that i can point at and be happy

but meowza lol

idk yall im making vibes reads cause tahts all i got the energy to put into thegame rn, i saw yall say zelda is like DOUBLE LOCK CLEAR off meta so poggywoggy thats awesome, i think my idivions of the list stands strong. im OMGUSING ladd today for hist readtmeant of my slot, im saying bennehs push on me being an arso is WILD and atp im not sure if hes serious about it or not

tn i give out another soft invest so if i get it off poggies

meow meow i hav never been so eepy in my life man fuck ww i deserve a long nap

[Visor]

*towns about*

idk yall the shit people are saying about my slot actually boggles my mind, idt anyone is really engaging with what ive said in a productive way but at the same time i havent engaged with the game nearly enough to have a body of work that i can point at and be happy

but meowza lol

idk yall im making vibes reads cause tahts all i got the energy to put into thegame rn, i saw yall say zelda is like DOUBLE LOCK CLEAR off meta so poggywoggy thats awesome, i think my idivions of the list stands strong. im OMGUSING ladd today for hist readtmeant of my slot, im saying bennehs push on me being an arso is WILD and atp im not sure if hes serious about it or not

tn i give out another soft invest so if i get it off poggies

meow meow i hav never been so eepy in my life man fuck ww i deserve a long nap

give it to me

buddy you gotta give me something to work with man

how am i supposed to v read u lol

[Maple]

give it to me

buddy you gotta give me something to work with man

how am i supposed to v read u lol

idk man im trying

[Visor]

inb4 this is the benneh/lissa redemption wolfrand from that turbo from like a decade ago

[nebjiamn]

inb4 this is the benneh/lissa redemption wolfrand from that turbo from like a decade ago

youll know its real if she finally claims seer in f5

[nebjiamn]

but truthfully we already had our wolf rand redemption in indie mash. at this point its vindiction rather than redemption

[ladd]

idk yall im making vibes reads cause tahts all i got the energy to put into thegame rn, i saw yall say zelda is like DOUBLE LOCK CLEAR off meta so poggywoggy thats awesome, i think my idivions of the list stands strong. im OMGUSING ladd today for hist readtmeant of my slot, im saying bennehs push on me being an arso is WILD and atp im not sure if hes serious about it or not

You voted me yesterday when i had yet to push you tho so that cannot possibly be the reason why you think i am a wolf

[Maple]

You voted me yesterday when i had yet to push you tho so that cannot possibly be the reason why you think i am a wolf

your vibes were fucked dawg i dont know what to tell you

[waza]

your vibes were fucked dawg i dont know what to tell you

meh i do read some of maples posts and i wonder wtf they would be doing if theyre a wolf, cos w!maple knows this type of stuff isnt gonna convince anyone

and maple can wolf really well if they wanna, so i get the argument that if maple were a wolf maybe they would play this differently

but eh it doubles up for them being town too lol

like if theyre town i highly value their town game too, so i need to ask if maple is town then what are they doing because i dont get it either

namely, they bring up d1 they have found their role in mafia to be somewhat of a mediator when they rand town, trying to keep town on their tracks and preventing people from fighting (im going off memory i could be misrepping here). but then yesterday would have been a prime situation for maple to put that into action when they found arctic towny and i assume trd ben, i dont recall if they really did anything to stop town from going downhill yesterday.

and my mental model of manti is someone whose really great at mech.

some of their posts here remind me of hsr where they were kinda free and reckless in their posting, which is an argument for v!maple. but also when maple fakeclaimed my role in hsr i could completely understand the logic behind it and they were towny outside of that too, which is why i let them claim my role (iirc someone sus was bombed and i imagine manti claimed my role to try and bait them into bombinb manti if mafia had bomb, and if not it would bait the nk) manti didnt express any of this but it felt clear to me

on the converse, whenever theyre a wolf and claim something i always find their claims confusing and somwhat -ev and have usually mentioned so in those games. over here it leans more to that because i really do think if i was in mantis shoes i never would have claimed that i gave out a track, it diminishes the value of the track entirely once people know its out. and the way manti played around it almost felt like they always planned on claiming that day (ie they softed the track in their first post and claimed far away from eod). so yeah idk not a fan of they played around the track stuff

[didistetter]

i'd kinda prefer to elim ender over lissa.

Read back ender's iso and i was giving him too much credit for some casual/shitposty stuff that vibed like decent tone and confidence, and even though i don't love Lissa's reaction to arctic/encouraging of ben's sus on arctic misreading his role, and it sucks she's been so afk this phase, i still think she has some ok moments where she just kinda feels ?fine? towny? dunno.

id probs prefer ender -> lissa -> maple

Biggest issue with manti is the fact she claimed at all. It rlly could equally be a wolf role made to give towncred or a town investigative role.
If we have town/3p arso, town inventor, and odd/even redirectbodyguards i really would expect wolf kp tho so... we might be working with pretty narrow chances to get this right

[Maple]

im too lazy to get the reciepts but i think its plausible that benneh geuninly didnt understand rasks role based on some of the shit he said

and some of hte setup spec he postesd

is that something he'd fake as w? like honestly its pretty crazy and longterm if he set that up as a derp d2 and executed upon it d3 after teh spec he posted yday esp wrt the arctic slot

[dyachei]

that was a very villagery observation on ender by visor

[Maple]

god the gotcha on arctic into the shit earlier about taff but also repping a fake derp on rask just seems like some *me* level bullshit and idt benneh has that crackhead dog in him

[Visor]

god the gotcha on arctic into the shit earlier about taff but also repping a fake derp on rask just seems like some *me* level bullshit and idt benneh has that crackhead dog in him

i mean he was doing this shit back in SSB mash days

the stop eating dinner thing is pure you level 'grey matter' stuff imo

like all the signs were there

[nebjiamn]

i mean he was doing this shit back in SSB mash days

the stop eating dinner thing is pure you level 'grey matter' stuff imo

like all the signs were there

fyi i voted a wolf so im lock clear

[Maple]

i mean he was doing this shit back in SSB mash days

the stop eating dinner thing is pure you level 'grey matter' stuff imo

like all the signs were there

meowby im just gonna put it here for now

[Maple]

god the gotcha on arctic into the shit earlier about taff but also repping a fake derp on rask just seems like some *me* level bullshit and idt benneh has that crackhead dog in him

if we turn this around it would go thusly

benneh busses rask d1 and n1 cooks up the ploy to setup for this shit d2+.

cashes in on cred to get PR!arctic killed yday, and attempts to regrab cred via the derp claim on d3

point in favour of this: he pinged us all with his incorrect perspective, counter: he never *really* pushed that pov in the thread and no one brought it up before me so like was he slowcooking it if w?

shrug

seems >randv

i know benneh is a crafty guy but fwict he favours good ol fashion strong wolf strats

his partner would have to have been both someone who didnt vote rask + most likely osmoneone in danger d1? lol i guess his partner could be me in that scenario

meow meow

idk seems v to me

[Visor]

heres what i think

i think both benneh and lissa were wolves around eod1 and did not want rask to go over, but knew that if he got momentum, they would need to capitalise on it

benneh is a smart wolf and he knows that giving rask an extra day and potential for more credit to villagers doesnt mean a lot when you can take that credit from villagers

i think they both talked it over and decided that if he became a wagon in the dying minutes they'd bus him, but otherwise sit around and see if they can't wait it out

lissa was throwing the seeds of the bus out there without actually committing

it is only when annika, stett and me vote rask that suddenly he becomes the lead wagon and then they decide alright lets pull the trigger

bit uncharitable of me i know but i am feeling uncharitable at the moment

[Visor]

im too lazy to get the reciepts but i think its plausible that benneh geuninly didnt understand rasks role based on some of the shit he said

and some of hte setup spec he postesd

is that something he'd fake as w? like honestly its pretty crazy and longterm if he set that up as a derp d2 and executed upon it d3 after teh spec he posted yday esp wrt the arctic slot

benneh is a crafty guy

i can see him wanting to do stuff like that to style on ppl

especially if he has a wolfbro that makes a team that feeds off each other to go further and further

[Totally not Taffy]

im too lazy to get the reciepts but i think its plausible that benneh geuninly didnt understand rasks role based on some of the shit he said

and some of hte setup spec he postesd

is that something he'd fake as w? like honestly its pretty crazy and longterm if he set that up as a derp d2 and executed upon it d3 after teh spec he posted yday esp wrt the arctic slot

He doesn't need to set something like that up as a wolf, it's just as possible that wolf!Benneh misread the role of an afk teammate as that town!Benneh misread the role of a flipped wolf for over 48hrs. Shit happens. Surely you can find something more meaningful to read Benneh off of?

Also you haven't answered my question

Taffy (15)

[ladd]

Why can rask self target? Because the wolves can bomb him and use it as a communication tool

I think they can self target just so they can defuse themselves if they get bombed

I really dont think taffy makes any sense as a wolf



Idk i personally wanna vote maple

But stett is voting ender and i promised id follow them blindly

But visor thinks ender v (ngl visor/ender w/w still in the back of my mind) and wants lissa and i kinds wanna give them this lunch after how yday went


Waza killed any tinfoil i had on them. Benneh last post is so weird

[Visor]

I'm fine to kill ender or maple

Neither have done anything and we are gonna keep going in circles around them until they die at this point

I still think Lissa is a wolf though

[ladd]

vote:lissa

Alrighty

[Totally not Taffy]

I think the wolfiest thing Lissa did today is express annoyance that I didn't use my kp last night. I'm sure wolves would love to see me kill a bunch of town. But it's not exactly damning. I was going to say "if there are three wolves left then Lissa can't be one of them bc she's the only wagon" but then I realised I was discounting the attempt to wagon me. It's still not really sitting well with me tbh.

Earlier when we had Ladd/Maple I was leaning voting Ladd bc I feel like town!Ladd should care more about helping me find Dyachei. But it makes zero sense for a wolf to defend me here I mean surely they'd prefer getting me misyeeted over using a NK on me and he can just... not.

In the same vein I need to retract my townread of Ender bc the jump between these posts

I think I'm happy with me/Lissa/Maple poe? I do think I've been letting Waza/Ladd go a little. Taffy's not wolf. Benneh's not wolf. Dya's not wolf. (I think) Pzelda is probably not a wolf (but god that theory on me was atrocious) Stett I keep getting paranoia about but everyone else agrees that they're town so I'm just telling myself to shut up there.

I mean I'm not against killing Taffy here because I think it's ~fairly likely she's 3p atm.

And while it's not clearing wolves it's never a bad idea. I don't think the lost wolf idea is that likely but I could be confbiasing myself.

feels really opportunistic. Townies shouldn't hunt for neutrals until all wolves are dead and the game doesn't end. It's not that he's buying into Benneh's tinpot theory, he knows I'm not a wolf, he just goes from "I'm not considering Taffy today" to "well I guess if you're offering who am I to resist". But it's such a self-centred read I don't like basing a vote on that.

So I guess

Vote: Maple

Taffy (16)

[ladd]

Vote: Lissa

vote:lissa

I forgot lol i saw you switched to ender lmk if u want me to switch