A Request to the Jousting Field

[barocca]

I read the posting in main hall of the developers replays,
and the commentary on the mistakes made in those games,
plus advice given on what to do to make a better showing next time,

I have a request of the members of The Jousting Fields,

Many of you save replays for further analysis, what i ask is you upload those replays here at the Org,
and dissect them in a post here,
point out errors, give advice,
If you lost then what do you think you did wrong?
If you won what could your opponent have done to make more of a challenge...

These types of discussions can only improve the quality of our new players, (or even old shogun hands like me who have a few difficulties adjusting to Medieval)

It is terribly boring to be comprehensively thrashed all the time, as i was when i first came online in 2000,
fortunately Obake, Widda, Yabusama and Amp all spent the time after a battle to explain what i did wrong and what i could have done to recover from the mistake, and what i perhaps should do next time i play...


Make the game more enjoyable for new players and we will see more of them hanging around to play day in and day out...

UPLOAD Recorded Battles here
Please Zipfile them, and include a tezt file with your email and any notes about the battle, perhaps even include the logfile for examination.

Direct Download of Replays
The Direct Download link will allow you to download a battle replay moments after it is uploaded, it will also help the poster to determine the file link to add to his thread.

[TenkiSoratoti]

Nice idea

But recorded battles grrrrr, ive already seen that and its a way to show off grrrr.
Arragance baaaah

[Alrowan]

not a bad idea, ive looked at the CA vs .Org game, and taken about 30 screenshots, im tempted to post them with some small bits of info here and there... also some humour

i tohught it was a really good battle of pointing out what to do and what not to do

[bosdur]

Not a bad idea, Probabaly give an incentive too, like senior membership after 10 analysis of replay .

[Swoosh So]

Nice idea alrowan post away

[Alrowan]

ok, ill try go through them all sometime tomorrow, make them into one or two files then post away

[baz]

good idea, i am hoping to start up a "what happened next" series where ppl can say what they would do in a similar situation hopefully ppl will enjoy that...coming soon.......