A slight unit ballancing issue: in normal MTW and also in XL vanilla pikemen are way to weak. In custom battles they require lots of upgrades to be somewhat reliable, and then they're not cost-effective. Chivalric sergeants, Italian infantry and order foot soldiers are much better despite being normal spear units.
Any tactical approach relying on pikemen is asking for disaster unless you're using Swiss pikemen, wich are hard to come by but can easily ensure victory once you train vast amounts of them.
Sure vanilla pikemen shouldn't be extraordinary fighters but they should at least be able to repel swordsmen from the front if their formation holds and their flanks are covered, as it is they fail to do that.
Proposed change: increase defense by +2 points (not the armour value though) and morale by +1. Another way to help them in campaign mode is to lower their required building upgrade by one. That will make them more accesible, and if you upgrade to the county militia you get +1 valour for them.
I looked forward to using them in my Crusader kingdom campaign (wich is a cool action btw), but because I'm only beginning with MTW again after not having played for so long I forgot how much they suck

I'm going to edit the stats myself for personal use, but I thought I should share my views.
Bookmarks