I just had a wonderful, epic battle online with a buddy of mine. An absolutely awesome battle where I played the Greek Cities and besieged a Julii Roman army in the Rome map. I barely won the battle, and I couldnt wait to watch the replay. I wonder if it was because of the length of the battle, but the replay came out wrong and showed me to have lost it. I really did win though, because we talked about it afterwards. He did log out just before the end, he got tired of sending the onesie twosie units that had rallied at me, so maybe that had something to do with it. For the love of God I really hope they fix the replays. I would have sent it, but I got mad and erased it.

I have also experienced that problem where I fought a battle and thought I won just to find out that my friend said that it showed he won, and the replay showed him to win. Guess Im just reiterating what has already been said before.