RTW: Erratic unit movement in battle

[Ptah]

My theory is that the concept of "groups" in RTW is quite a bit different from that of MTW. There is a high chance that it could be a bug, but it might also be a feature. The 'grouped' units in RTW have a strong tendency to try to retain its initial formation and unit positions, and thus more often than not it seems the units try to maintain the general formation while it is on the move.

The problem usually manifests when there are multiple units in groups which have different special abilities or movement speeds, and when the group is assigned to move over long distances. For instance, a group of Phalanx wielding infantry mixed with normal infantry does not respond to "run" command very well. As much, a group of missile cavalry mixed with normal cavalry sometimes fails to respond to attack inputs, because the missile cavalry may have "skirmish" mode on.

Therefore, the best method so far, is to make quick use of the "G" key and group only upon need. If the "group" command in MTW was more or less static, in RTW it is flexible. You want to keep grouping and disbanding units during battle according to the situation. Usually the static line playing the role of the "anvil" is preferred to be grouped, while the units playing the "hammer" role may be grouped initially, but quickly dispersed according to situation.

[Arakasi]

Well the main problem I've had with grouping was evident during my attempt at winning the Tutenborg forest battle. I had a group of three Roman infantry units (non archer/non cav) who I was trying to move and they would not move. I had to ungroup them and group them again to make them move. Or select them individually. Moving them as a group was useless.

[TN[ KrAzY!]

first off rome is awesome, the last few nites ive been up untill about 6am with "just one more turn" going through my mind but i have encountered some of these bugs too, most notably the scatty unit behaviour, first time was when i was playing greeks in multyplayer my spartan general on my flank refused to move from his spot in the phalanx line, his unit was unengaged on the flank so ithought id do the typical phalanx tactic of rolling up the enemies flanks, however when i tried to issue my gen with orders he absolutley refused to obey, he just stood immobile, was very frustrating. also the grouped unit running thing has happened to me when ive had only units if the exact same type grouped together.

[foop]

The 'grouped' units in RTW have a strong tendency to try to retain its initial formation and unit positions, and thus more often than not it seems the units try to maintain the general formation while it is on the move.

That sounds plausible. In my last battle I almost lost the center of my front line when two grouped units of velites just stood around ignoring my orders. In the end they started moving again once I'd ungrouped them and reissued orders.

I've had more experience with city battles since I started this thread, too, and have had more problems. I wasn't very happy with the unit of archers who insisted on walking down a broad avenue in single file hugging the east wall.

Minor annoyances aside, it's still a great game.

[Spuddicus]

One of my favorites so far ...
4 units of archers with 2 phalanxes in front take up a postion just outside the town center square and open up on the enemy phalanxes.
This should be a turkey shoot.
But then I notice all of my archer unit numbers are in red ... and dropping quickly.
Lovely.
My phalanxes in front are not getting hit and neither are the enemy's.
I went from roughly 400 archers in those units to less than 200 in the blink of an eye.