I tried it a couple times over. The kills were still about the same. A cretan archer with 3/4 of his arrows would kill just over half of the armored hoplites. Damn I wish I could post in those threads to chime in with the numbers that I've gotten. Or at least get the discussion to come over here. All the serious RTW discussion goes on in that forum. Maybe I'll try my charging method with cataphracts again with the huge attacks so I can see if it is the kill rate that is changing things.