I dont think I owe anyone an apology, considering I have avoided personal attacks in my entire time on this forum.Originally Posted by ToranagaSama
![]()
I am conservative by nature, and I was giving the developers the benefit of the doubt. I like to complete at least one campaign of a game before deciding wether its 'good' or 'bad', x is unbalanced, the AI sucks, etc.
I do admit that I was caught up a bit in RTWs "oh-ah" and the hype, I still think some of complaints are unwarrented, but I am now seeing many of the MTW veterins side of things, and yes there also was a bit of devils advocate going on (someones gotta do it).
I still think RTW is the better game, but only just. This is my point, it should be a significantly better game even without all its irritating bugs.
Simon, RTW brings a lot of things that when I first started playing MTW I wish were there (populations, diplomacy, mainly strategy map stuff). Yes the battlefield AI isnt that wonderful in MTW either, but overall i THINK its less frustrating.Interesting perspective, Morindin. I am not sure how much you played MTW before RTW but I can't agree that RTW only scores by virtue of sounds and graphics (these things mean very little to me), or that the two games don't feel alike.
I played MTW regularly since it came out so naturally I think very highly of it. However, there were a number of negative features that seem absent in RTW. The MTW battle engine might be more to my taste (killing and charge speeds), but the battles themselves were not necessarily better because the AI fielded dire troops (on early) - eg peasants, ballistas, archers - and because the reinforcement issue was a major drag (the first wave could be a challenge, but then you could spend half an hour dealing with dross). I actually have come to like the brisk pace of RTW battles - with MTW, you would be scared of ending a turn late at night, because several battles might errupt that required 3 or more hours to play out manually.
The MTW strategic map was much less involving to me - moving armies round on the RTW campaign map reminds me of the way an army really moves and does not feel like Civ at all (that game had incredibly tedious combat with moving scores of weak units one or two squares at a time). In terms of grand strategy, the ability of the player (only) to get rich in MTW by trade arguably broke the game. Plus the inability of the AI to make peace, coupled with pointless wars sparked off by piracy, made the strategic layer lose some interest.
I don't know how you can say the games don't feel alike - to me the battles and the building elements of all three Total War games are virtually identical in terms of what you do and quite unlike any other games I have played (well, less so the building elements, but the battle engine is still pretty unique).
Maybe I'll feel differently when I've played more RTW, but I found it hard to go back to STW after MTW and suspect the same will be true about leaving RTW for MTW.
Some of the things you dont like about MTW however I do like! (the whole reinforcement thing for example) :)
The trade thing could really break MTW yes, but personally I didnt 'exploit' it when I played, only putting ships in 'realistic' places. Arguably the whole crappy ship system in RTW is almost worse (however Im playing around with modding the attack rate on ships). Also why cant CA give you fleets of ships? Instead of 120men and ONE ship why cant we had squadrons of ships? Some of the battles between Carthage and Rome involved HUNDREDS of ships. Anyway, I disgress.
If you read my post Im pretty critical about MTW, but its a much older game now so I think it gets 'more excuses'.
Anyway I cant see myself playing many more than 2 campaigns in RTW until an expansion pack. I might head off into multiplayer world, but really for games of this scope and size, that's pretty sad (I've probably completed the Baldurs Gate2 campaign 10 times - now THAT is an Epic game!). I guess its party due to the fact that im not really interested in playing barbarian (or fighting, who here is sick to death of fighting Barbarians?) factions and there are so many of them in Rome.
Bookmarks