I find that especially when patches are first released people jump to conclusions based on single episodes of the elephants not living up to the "battlefield gods" mentality that was grained into everyone's minds since the demo. Even after posting these results in another forum there were still people saying that they were underpowered. Most hear one thing and don't try it for themselves, or they have one bad time with the elephants and it tarnishes their whole opinion of the elephants. I find that now it really depends more on how they are used on how effective they are. Use them like big Horses.
Bookmarks