This topic is going deep beyond it's point I think. This reads like a backroom thread.

There don't seem to be any "sides" to this, as everybody has their own opinion, which is interesting IMO. Anyway, my opinion is that at the end of the day modders can do what they want, and if they release it to the public then "whatever". The only thing the public has a right to say is either suggesting ways of improving it (partly by pointing out bugs) or complement it. The modder isn't paid by the public, so who cares if they dislike it? It's his/her mod, he/she can do whatever he/she wants with it. I think it really is as simple as that, to be honest.