It is interesting that modding (in the case of RTR) has such differing opinions.

There are some people that will never be happy with any mod and expect perfection from modders. Comments like "it sucks" aren't constructive and don't contribute anything. I have seen the results of heavy handed criticism that results in fewer modders willing to release mods.

On the other side of the spectrum there seems to be the apologists that ruthlessly attack any criticism of the mod often engaging in the most immature personal attacks and name calling. I believe these people actually hurt a mod by discouraging criticism and promoting an attitude of indifference to the users of the MOD. This unblinking support can pump up egos and may explain why RTR 4.0 was premature released.

There are two extremes here. Nether of them are helpful.