Stupid question, re: attacking with archers

[Irinami]

I like my archers and Arquebustierres in close combat... at the right point. Wedge of Envelope, downhill, always try to flank. Their proximity to the battle can carry the day, erasing penalties for your main melee'ers being outnumbered and/or adding penalties onto the enemy for same. My 'Bustierres killed Mori last night. He attacked Awaji (I love defending there) in heavy rain. I used 2 cav units dancing around his flanks and rear to peel off 3 of his units. Long story short, my hidden 'Bustierres couldn't fire, so I held them in reserve. After loosing all my arrows and sending the archers in to support the yari spearmen (lost a fresh unit of No-Tachi in a delaying attack), I committed my tired cav to downhill attacks on his Very Tired Yari Spearmen. Lord Mori helped one of his spearmen, so the 'Bustierres charged in. Uphill behind him, but since they're so spread out they wrapped around him and his yaris. By the end, I had everyone on just him. It was great... "4 Heavy Cavalry (Mori)... 3 HC (Mori)..." Mori himself lasted a good 2 minutes, and my 'Bustierres were the ones who gained honor when he died. Very satisfying.

So short version: Use them indirectly to flank a tied-up unit which is giving you problems. Set them either on a very broad front or a Wedge and charge into them downhill or from flat terrain at worst. Once that threat is gone, you've probably got more profitable things for them to be doing. In My Newbie Opinion. ;)

[Sasaki Kojiro]

It's my opinion that if you have to send your archers in then you've done something wrong...rather than thinking about when it is right to send them in and how a good general will come up with tactics for winning without them.

[Wilbo]

True but I'm sure they can be used to turn the tide of a battle... If you have an army of 1 SA and 1 Ashi defending (though arguably you have made a mistake of guarding an edge territory with such a small army), it is sometimes neccesary to run downhill and flank a few Ashi units to send em runnin'

[Oda Gerritianus]

Archers are great against other archers or against low level Asighu

Sometimes I used armies of only archers, try it there a pain in the ass to beat

[Irinami]

I don't agree that you have done something wrong if you have to engage the enemy with your archers in close combat. They are warriors, on the battlefield for a reason. It would be foolish not to use them to their fullest. Just... don't use them foolishly or capriciously, for as Sasaki-san suggests they are not your primary melee troops.

[Togakure]

Doing the unexpected, being unpredictable, is a formidable weapon in war. I think it is usually a mistake to say that one should never do this or that. Do what a situation calls for, however unconventional it might seem out of context.

I use archers to attack effectively, usually against other archers or ashigaru, or against the flanks or rear of any troops that are engaged with other troops. You can often affect an enemy unit's morale such that they flee with a well-timed and angled double-team.

Sasaki doesn't need to melee attack with archers because his mastery of tactics and control on this game's battlefield far exceed those of most Shogun MP players I've encountered. I can testify to this because I've battled against him many, many times (and lost, mostly). If you would like some lessons in frustration, meet him for 1v1 battles on the Fakeserver, or using the Samurai Wars mod for MTW.

[Drisos]

Doing the unexpected, being unpredictable, is a formidable weapon in war. I think it is usually a mistake to say that one should never do this or that. Do what a situation calls for, however unconventional it might seem out of context.

I use archers to attack effectively, usually against other archers or ashigaru, or against the flanks or rear of any troops that are engaged with other troops. You can often affect an enemy unit's morale such that they flee with a well-timed and angled double-team.

Sasaki doesn't need to melee attack with archers because his mastery of tactics and control on this game's battlefield far exceed those of most Shogun MP players I've encountered. I can testify to this because I've battled against him many, many times (and lost, mostly). If you would like some lessons in frustration, meet him for 1v1 battles on the Fakeserver, or using the Samurai Wars mod for MTW.

These are the words of an expert!!!!!!