Quote Originally Posted by Red Harvest
I compare it to its siblings, and how much doesn't work right, and how much time I've had to spend modding it. 75 to 80% looks about right.

The battlefield AI problem alone hacks off a minimum of 10% probably more like 15%. Then there are the number of unpatched remaining flaws and bugs, with essentially a single patch policy... I was probably too generous with my score.
I voted the same way, and felt I was too generous as well... but I was mainly voting for the potential, not the actual game...