rate the game

[clayton ballentine]

what do you say about RTW or MTW i

[ichi]

I gave a 7 to STW WE and MTW VI, Rome would get a 4.

ichi

[Uesugi Kenshin]

9.5 for STW, though that may partly be nostalgia speaking. 9.4 for MTW:VI and an 8.3 to RTW. No matter what I am just too caught up in making an empire and following my core family members to care too much about the problems. Besides when I get frustrated I switch to an FPS or a mod and de-stress.

[clayton ballentine]

Rome would get a 4.

ichi

a four

[Shambles]

STW
Easy 10 Becous i love it

MTW
Gets 8 Becous its realy Good. And campaign is tougher than STW In the VI
Would have had 10, But i had to buy VI to make it tougher than shogun

RTW
3 ish and im being kind there cos i uninstalled the game and Refuse to play it as it sux
It only gets points becous of its gfx and the few additions they made to rome,
Becous its really is unplayable, If you have any of the other 2 games,
You will just play the other 2
As the AI Is appauling,
They never bothered finishing the game,
And they riped me off for almost £50 for something I wouldnt even use to rest my cup of coffe on

[Drisos]

Hello, clayton ballentine! Nice to see you in sword dojo.

A ten for STW. I'd say both for MTW and RTW a one because these games made STW lose so many players.

[ichi]

a four

LMAO

[viermaaldomi]

a 10 , both for STW and MTW.I haven't played rome yet (I'll buy it when they release the BI expansion pack)

[Razor1952]

You guys are a bit harsh.

I rate STW:WI , MTW:VI and RTW overall the same mark say 8

.

STW:WI gets its mark because I love the simplicity of the campaign (clearly defined strategies can be used) battle mode is fun but graphics hardly topnotch.

MTW:VI because some of the campaign things are good strategy fun(like acumen/leadership/titles) but together with RTW suffers from needless complexity fro micro-management. Battle AI the best of the 3 , graphics OK but not stunning

RTW(I only play mods) because the graphics are awesome fun and the field battles are great extravaganzas, but I'm not so keen on continual sieging and fighting my way through city streets where pathing becomes a bugbear.


So all equal for different reasons. Personally I'd love to play STW with RTW graphics. That is a campaign map which is not degraded by needless detail for optimal management , field battles with awesome graphics.

[Drisos]

Personally I'd love to play STW with RTW graphics. That is a campaign map which is not degraded by needless detail for optimal management , field battles with awesome graphics.

me too, actually, but I think STW is already great.

The SJ:TW is exactly what you mean, same idea(japan, sengoku jidai) RTW grafics. I think I'll give that one a try when it's finished.