Well Ive played all three now, and I just keep coming back to STWWE.

I cant put my finger on it, the graphics are dated, the interface in many ways is tedious, but I can play it for hours on end.

RTW looks better, MTW has more stuff, but STW is just more fun. I really feel like I am there, the suspension of reality is STILL alive when I play that game.Maybe because CA went over board with the complexity of MTW/RTW.

I wish CA would give STW a face lift, and just a few improvements.

RTW ill keep fooling around with.

BUT STWWE is just better, IMO