Poll: Missile or Melee?

Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 30 of 38

Thread: Pontic Heavy Cavalry

  1. #1

    Default Pontic Heavy Cavalry

    Do you class them as Melee or Missile cavalry?

    i have always thought of them as a weak heavy melee unit but its been argued that they are a true missile unit due to "cantibrain circle" and they can skirmish.

    i used to think that they were melee, i am not sure if the name "Pontic heavy cavalry" made me thought that they were heavy cavalry. they are a decent melee unit and can beat most light cavalry but against heavy cavalry get beat by everything.

    therefor i think they are missile, but are mis-seen as melee due to their name

  2. #2
    Blue Eyed Samurai Senior Member Wishazu's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2002
    Location
    Great Britain
    Posts
    1,679

    Default Re: Pontic Heavy Cavalry

    i agree with missile, me and preston just had a massive discussion about this on xfire.
    "Wishazu does his usual hero thing and slices all the zombies to death, wiping out yet another horde." - Askthepizzaguy, Resident Evil: Dark Falls

    "Move not unless you see an advantage; use not your troops unless there is something to be gained; fight not unless the position is critical"
    Sun Tzu the Art of War

    Blue eyes for our samurai
    Red blood for his sword
    Your ronin days are over
    For your home is now the Org
    By Gregoshi

  3. #3
    Senior Member Senior Member Cheetah's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2001
    Location
    Hungary
    Posts
    2,085

    Default Re: Pontic Heavy Cavalry

    Technically missile, practically can be both.
    Lional of Cornwall
    proud member of the Round Table Knights
    ___________________________________
    Death before dishonour.

    "If you wish to weaken the enemy's sword, move first, fly in and cut!" - Ueshiba Morihei O-Sensei

  4. #4

    Default Re: Pontic Heavy Cavalry

    Erm. Both? Why is there no both option?

    I use them to pepper with their javelins (theres not that many and it won't take long) and then charge them in, or flank with them.

    You guys think too much in "black and white" as they say. There is sometimes a grey you know?

  5. #5
    Blue Eyed Samurai Senior Member Wishazu's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2002
    Location
    Great Britain
    Posts
    1,679

    Default Re: Pontic Heavy Cavalry

    black and white has nothing to do with it, this is to do with the sets of rules that people play with online. One of the most common is 5 max missile cav and 5 max melee cav, in a couple of games recently ive played as pontus and have been accused of cheating because i took 4 cappadocians and a chariot as my melee cav and 4 pontic heavy cav as my missile cav. this poll is purely to determine what everyone thinks they should be classed as.
    "Wishazu does his usual hero thing and slices all the zombies to death, wiping out yet another horde." - Askthepizzaguy, Resident Evil: Dark Falls

    "Move not unless you see an advantage; use not your troops unless there is something to be gained; fight not unless the position is critical"
    Sun Tzu the Art of War

    Blue eyes for our samurai
    Red blood for his sword
    Your ronin days are over
    For your home is now the Org
    By Gregoshi

  6. #6
    Ultimate Member tibilicus's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2005
    Location
    England
    Posts
    2,663

    Default Re: Pontic Heavy Cavalry

    Tuff one. I should of voted misile but i voted melle because thats what i use them as. There misiles dont really do much damage andd dont last all that long. Maby put a rule not only 5 max melle cav and 5 max misile cav but 5 max skirmishing cav? Dont know if it would work though.


    "A lamb goes to the slaughter but a man, he knows when to walk away."

  7. #7
    Blue Eyed Samurai Senior Member Wishazu's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2002
    Location
    Great Britain
    Posts
    1,679

    Default Re: Pontic Heavy Cavalry

    whats the difference between missile cav and skirmishing cav?
    "Wishazu does his usual hero thing and slices all the zombies to death, wiping out yet another horde." - Askthepizzaguy, Resident Evil: Dark Falls

    "Move not unless you see an advantage; use not your troops unless there is something to be gained; fight not unless the position is critical"
    Sun Tzu the Art of War

    Blue eyes for our samurai
    Red blood for his sword
    Your ronin days are over
    For your home is now the Org
    By Gregoshi

  8. #8

    Default Re: Pontic Heavy Cavalry

    Pontic heavy cav should be classified as missile in my opinion...

    RTKCharlemagne

  9. #9
    Ultimate Member tibilicus's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2005
    Location
    England
    Posts
    2,663

    Default Re: Pontic Heavy Cavalry

    I see misile cav as Horse archers and cataphract archers. I see skirmishing cav as Pontic heavy cav,militia cav e.c.t. The main diference is that most skirmishing cav use javalins to throw and also are ment to be used for attaking purposes to. The idea of turning on your enemy as they pursue is one tatic I love. It's not really classed like this i think i just classt it like this. As the diference between javalin armed cav and archer armed cav is genrely Javalin cav can put up a fight vs other cav. HA get wasted. Sorry if this does not make sense im dead tired.........


    "A lamb goes to the slaughter but a man, he knows when to walk away."

  10. #10

    Default Re: Pontic Heavy Cavalry

    that isn't strictly true though tib.

    Cataphract Archers......... they're the best ranged cav unit that can stand up to cavalry for a bit. but jav cav can not compete with heavy cav, they gets destroyed with most HA fairing even worse.
    Last edited by Lord Preston; 07-09-2005 at 11:21.

  11. #11

    Default Re: Pontic Heavy Cavalry

    Depends on what you intend to use them for.

    But if we are defining rules, I define them as melee cav.

    Technically, when playing as Pontus there, you have 4 cappadocians and 4 heavy pontics. If it came down to it, the heavies could be used as a decisive melee force.

  12. #12

    Default Re: Pontic Heavy Cavalry

    but couldn't Cataphract Archers be used as a decisive melee force? so would you call them melee cavalry as well?


    4 caps + 4 pontic heavies vs 8 legionnary cav
    or vs 8 gothic will get destroyed.

    im not sure how you can say pontic heavy cav can be decisive melee, they are worse than all the heavy melee cav and even some light cav can beat them.

    the only way i can see them being decisive is if they are used to flank, but then ANY cavalry can be decicive if used to flank.

  13. #13
    Ultimate Member tibilicus's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2005
    Location
    England
    Posts
    2,663

    Default Re: Pontic Heavy Cavalry

    Heres what gets me. Cat archers are ment to have the same attack as catas but be able to use msisles as well. However this is not true. I remeber in an armenia campaign I was against some sacred band cav. I thinking my Cata archers would kick but put them on melee mode. However when they charged they got compleatly destroyed. Oh well. I guess it's yet another imbalanced thing in RTW.


    "A lamb goes to the slaughter but a man, he knows when to walk away."

  14. #14

    Default Re: Pontic Heavy Cavalry

    exacly, if Cata Archers the ranged cav unit with the best melee can't even beat melee cav, how can a unit that is worse at melee and use missiles be classed as melee?

  15. #15
    Legendary Member Taurus's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2005
    Location
    Kwang Tung
    Posts
    1,985

    Default Re: Pontic Heavy Cavalry

    I class Pontic Heavy Cavalry as melee cavalry. I do this because of a simple reason.
    Do you class urban cohorts as missile units just because they throw javelins?
    I class Pontic Heavy cav as melee because in my opinion and in the way that I use them they throw a volley of javelins and then charge the enemy therefore I class them as melee.

    Thanks,
    - Vip3r Warrior

  16. #16

    Default Re: Pontic Heavy Cavalry

    you made the exact point that i made, but compairing a roman cohort unit to a cavalry unit is a bit dodgy.

    urbans are the best hand to hand infantry with javalins as a bonus

    while pontic heavy cavalry are a rubbish melee unit and do more damage with javalines.
    Last edited by Lord Preston; 07-09-2005 at 16:41.

  17. #17

    Default Re: Pontic Heavy Cavalry

    Well, in one way you look at it, the rule is flawed. All missile cav can be used as melee cav. Sacred band are an elite melee cav, so it's understandable theat they would beat CA's.

    I suggest a new rule: 10 max cav, No more than 4 of the same unit.

  18. #18
    Ultimate Member tibilicus's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2005
    Location
    England
    Posts
    2,663

    Default Re: Pontic Heavy Cavalry

    Quote Originally Posted by Craterus
    . Sacred band are an elite melee cav, so it's understandable theat they would beat CA's.
    Thats the case, but acording to unit stats it shouldn't be like that. CA have attak value of 9 and defense of 17 + there very hevily armoured cav. Sacred band i can't remember the stats for but if CA have slightly less defense than normal catas but 2 more attack points than normal catas they should then beat armoured cav such as sacred band.
    Last edited by tibilicus; 07-09-2005 at 18:51.


    "A lamb goes to the slaughter but a man, he knows when to walk away."

  19. #19

    Default Re: Pontic Heavy Cavalry

    Tibilicus - it's not always as simple as stats comparision where CAs have a melee attack of 9, defence 22 versus the SB cavalry with 12 attack and 18 defence. Factors such as fatigue play a huge role, which would especially be the case after cataphract archers have been firing for a while. Other issues also determine who wins the cavalry duel, such as how you charge your cavalry, terrain, nearby troops etc. Yes, with both of them being fresh, in equal numbers, unupgraded, unsupported and handled the same way, CAs would win versus SB cav more often than they lose, but this would be a close call, but this kind of situation would never really happen in a real battle.

    Cataphracts are far superior melee fighters to CAs, as they have an armour piercing mace as their secondary weapon dealing a base attack of 9.

    While Cataphract archers are powerful, they are expensive, which I think doesn't give Armenia an unfair advantage in these rules, as you should be able to deal with them using superior infantry numbers should they melee.
    Last edited by NihilisticCow; 07-09-2005 at 20:44.

  20. #20
    Blue Eyed Samurai Senior Member Wishazu's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2002
    Location
    Great Britain
    Posts
    1,679

    Default Re: Pontic Heavy Cavalry

    Quote Originally Posted by Vip3r Warrior
    I class Pontic Heavy Cavalry as melee cavalry. I do this because of a simple reason.
    Do you class urban cohorts as missile units just because they throw javelins?
    I class Pontic Heavy cav as melee because in my opinion and in the way that I use them they throw a volley of javelins and then charge the enemy therefore I class them as melee.

    Thanks,
    - Vip3r Warrior
    But roman legionaries will only throw one volley of pila before charging into attack if you order them to attack, Pontic cav will keep throwing volley after volley into the selected enemy unit and even when they run out of ammo will continue to skirmish untill ordered to do otherwise.
    "Wishazu does his usual hero thing and slices all the zombies to death, wiping out yet another horde." - Askthepizzaguy, Resident Evil: Dark Falls

    "Move not unless you see an advantage; use not your troops unless there is something to be gained; fight not unless the position is critical"
    Sun Tzu the Art of War

    Blue eyes for our samurai
    Red blood for his sword
    Your ronin days are over
    For your home is now the Org
    By Gregoshi

  21. #21
    Ultimate Member tibilicus's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2005
    Location
    England
    Posts
    2,663

    Default Re: Pontic Heavy Cavalry

    Thats what legions did historicly. Lob some pila, charge. Skirmishing cav would haras enemy cav then ride off. So i supose they are diferent.


    "A lamb goes to the slaughter but a man, he knows when to walk away."

  22. #22

    Default Re: Pontic Heavy Cavalry

    also urbans dont have the skirmish ability, while pontic heavy cav do

    i think the pontic heavy cavalry are just a heavly armoured version of pontic light cavalry. which is a skirmisher cav classed as missile, so the heavy version should be to.

    -----------
    Craterus: the 10 max cav with no more than 4 of one type would not do the same as 5 melee + 5 missile.

    rome could take 4 prat, 4 legion and 2 roman cav.

    seleucids could take 4 cats + 4 comp (or mac, can't remember which)

    mac could take 4 comp + 4 mac

    but then factions like pontus only have cap cav which are good melee cav
    carthage only have SB cav and 2 light cav units
    germania only has Gothic.

    so with the rule you said you are seriously limiting the factions playable. you might as well have a 8 max melee cav rule but then thats nothing like the 5+5 cav rule.
    Last edited by Lord Preston; 07-09-2005 at 22:22.

  23. #23
    Legendary Member Taurus's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2005
    Location
    Kwang Tung
    Posts
    1,985

    Default Re: Pontic Heavy Cavalry

    But roman legionaries will only throw one volley of pila before charging into attack if you order them to attack, Pontic cav will keep throwing volley after volley into the selected enemy unit and even when they run out of ammo will continue to skirmish untill ordered to do otherwise.
    Wishazu - the only reason I compared them to urbans is because I coudn't think of anything else, lol.
    Sorry if I have caused much dismay among this thread but perhaps I should compare them to Velites then.
    Yes mounted velites or better still cavalry auxillia.

    However I still count them as melee and use them as melee units no matter how strong or weak they may be.

    also urbans dont have the skirmish ability, while pontic heavy cav do
    I know this to be true but as I said above ^ it's nothing to do with the urbans but I was just stating that just because they throw javelins doesn't mean they have to be classed as missile troops, (to me anyway.)

    But thats just my opinion.

    Thanks

  24. #24

    Default Re: Pontic Heavy Cavalry

    However I still count them as melee and use them as melee units no matter how strong or weak they may be.
    i think this is totally flawed, why would you use a strong missile unit that is weak at melee as melee? if you were to follow this line of thought then any unit can be used and classed as melee.... no matter how good or bad they are.

    i still think they are more elite missile cavalry than rubbish melee cavalry.

    think of them as pharohs guard or Chosen archers, they are decent melee units and can be used as such, but could never be classed as melee.
    Last edited by Lord Preston; 07-10-2005 at 16:49.

  25. #25
    Blue Eyed Samurai Senior Member Wishazu's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2002
    Location
    Great Britain
    Posts
    1,679

    Default Re: Pontic Heavy Cavalry

    well said preston
    "Wishazu does his usual hero thing and slices all the zombies to death, wiping out yet another horde." - Askthepizzaguy, Resident Evil: Dark Falls

    "Move not unless you see an advantage; use not your troops unless there is something to be gained; fight not unless the position is critical"
    Sun Tzu the Art of War

    Blue eyes for our samurai
    Red blood for his sword
    Your ronin days are over
    For your home is now the Org
    By Gregoshi

  26. #26
    Legendary Member Taurus's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2005
    Location
    Kwang Tung
    Posts
    1,985

    Default Re: Pontic Heavy Cavalry

    I am very sorry but I must stick to my guns.
    It is just my opinion. I just use Pontic heavy cavalry alongside the cappodician cavalry as melee units.

    Pontic Heavy Cavalry are melee cavalry in my opinion

  27. #27
    Blue Eyed Samurai Senior Member Wishazu's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2002
    Location
    Great Britain
    Posts
    1,679

    Default Re: Pontic Heavy Cavalry

    so far the poll is pretty close with missile just edging out melee. i woulda thought the gap would be bigger from the get go but....
    "Wishazu does his usual hero thing and slices all the zombies to death, wiping out yet another horde." - Askthepizzaguy, Resident Evil: Dark Falls

    "Move not unless you see an advantage; use not your troops unless there is something to be gained; fight not unless the position is critical"
    Sun Tzu the Art of War

    Blue eyes for our samurai
    Red blood for his sword
    Your ronin days are over
    For your home is now the Org
    By Gregoshi

  28. #28

    Default Re: Pontic Heavy Cavalry

    Also, heavy cavalry kinda screams MELEE at you.

    Oh yeah, and how are they elite missile cavalry? Call them missile cavalry if you will, but they are not elite. I can think of other mounted-missile units that outclass them.

    Scythian Noble Archers
    Scythian Noble Women
    Scythian Horse Archers
    Horse Archers
    Chariot Archers
    Cataphract Archers
    Persian Cavalry

    Arrows outclass javelins because there are many more volleys, and as we're evaluating their missile ability, you can't bring melee superiority into it.
    Last edited by Craterus; 07-13-2005 at 21:39.

  29. #29
    Blue Eyed Samurai Senior Member Wishazu's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2002
    Location
    Great Britain
    Posts
    1,679

    Default Re: Pontic Heavy Cavalry

    they are elite for pontus, the american Delta Force are an elite unit, buy they are shit compared to the british SAS or SBS.
    "Wishazu does his usual hero thing and slices all the zombies to death, wiping out yet another horde." - Askthepizzaguy, Resident Evil: Dark Falls

    "Move not unless you see an advantage; use not your troops unless there is something to be gained; fight not unless the position is critical"
    Sun Tzu the Art of War

    Blue eyes for our samurai
    Red blood for his sword
    Your ronin days are over
    For your home is now the Org
    By Gregoshi

  30. #30
    Ultimate Member tibilicus's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2005
    Location
    England
    Posts
    2,663

    Default Re: Pontic Heavy Cavalry

    Well i suppose if you just want this argument plain and simple you could argue it can't be anything other than a missile unit. All missile units carry some form of missile be it arrow and bow or javelin. The fact remains that any mounted unit wich has some form of missile and can skirmish making the title missile cav. This argument will probably remain a matter of personal opinion. So if there was ever going to be a rule change i doubt it could ever work as there would always be a disagreement wever this is missile or melee cavalry unit. Also Craterus, It may surprise you what javelins can do. I have actually found them quite effective. Any way this poll has totaly confused me so if i comment any more it will probably come out as nonsense. Any way enough said
    Tibilicus
    Last edited by tibilicus; 07-13-2005 at 23:30.


    "A lamb goes to the slaughter but a man, he knows when to walk away."

Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  
Single Sign On provided by vBSSO