This is not an exception, I must disagree. No where does the BoR apply to non-US citizens.
Its an exception as far as US citizens losing their rights in jail. I agree that the BoR dosent extend to those not citizens here but thats not the premise thats being disscussed. Its do we believe that everyone in the world has or should have these rights. I believe they should Therfore it apllies in ths disscussion as to whether they should be treated as if they were citizens. Again I believe those in Gitmo are being treated better than the arverage US citizen is who are being held in US jails.