Yet another case that shows why the death penalty is such a bad idea

[Xiahou]

Death-row convicts have also escaped. I don't think poor prison oversight a very strong argument.

edit:

Well sentencing people to prison once they are convicted of a crime - is not because of any other principle but retribution (SP) for their commiting a crime against society. That some prisons attempt to reform the convicted individual does not negate what the principle of prisons are all about. To serve justice for one's criminal act. Ie vengence of society upon the wrong-doer.

First, you're not killing someone for revenge- like I said. Second, I see other purposes than retribution as apparent. As you mention, reform- but also it is a deterrent. Also, while they are in prison they are unable to re-offend. So, yes, I think there are many other reasons above retribution. In fact, I don't put any stock at all in foggy notions such as retribution or societal balance as reasons for criminal justice.