Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 30 of 43

Thread: Tolkien's Fantasy World Too True To be Fantasy ?

  1. #1
    Boy's Guard Senior Member LeftEyeNine's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2003
    Location
    Yozgat
    Posts
    5,168

    Default Tolkien's Fantasy World Too True To be Fantasy ?

    There are many rumors J.R.R. Tolkien's Middle Earth being inspired by the real world. It is something impossible for a writer not to be effected by his/her reality but even every race is assigned to a real one by some people. Although I heard that Tolkien had denied the reality basis of his fantasy world, there are certain things you easily can relate to the reality.

    Any info's / comments ?

  2. #2
    "'elp! I'm bein' repressed!" Senior Member Aenlic's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2005
    Location
    The live music capital of the world.
    Posts
    1,583

    Default Re: Tolkien's Fantasy World Too True To be Fantasy ?

    Tolkien did indeed deny that his writings were in any way allegorical. He did admit that his experiences in war had a great effect on his stories, though. Many people have tried to claim some correspondence between the Lord of the Rings and WWII, particularly an imagined similarity between Hitler and Sauron. This is, of course, patently absurd. Tolkien began writing the stories during WWI, while serving in the trenches, including being sent to the horrors of the Somme. If any war affected the stories, it would be that war. Most of the basic foundations for his stories were laid long before WWII and the rise to power of Hitler.
    "Dee dee dee!" - Annoymous (the "differently challenged" and much funnier twin of Anonymous)

  3. #3
    EB Token Radical Member QwertyMIDX's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2005
    Location
    Providence, Rhode Island
    Posts
    5,898

    Default Re: Tolkien's Fantasy World Too True To be Fantasy ?

    There is some serious Racism in there though, that's all real world inspiration.
    History is for the future not the past. The dead don't read.


    Operam et vitam do Europae Barbarorum.

    History does not repeat itself. The historians repeat one another. - Max Beerbohm

  4. #4
    Praefectus Fabrum Senior Member Anime BlackJack Champion, Flash Poker Champion, Word Up Champion, Shape Game Champion, Snake Shooter Champion, Fishwater Challenge Champion, Rocket Racer MX Champion, Jukebox Hero Champion, My House Is Bigger Than Your House Champion, Funky Pong Champion, Cutie Quake Champion, Fling The Cow Champion, Tiger Punch Champion, Virus Champion, Solitaire Champion, Worm Race Champion, Rope Walker Champion, Penguin Pass Champion, Skate Park Champion, Watch Out Champion, Lawn Pac Champion, Weapons Of Mass Destruction Champion, Skate Boarder Champion, Lane Bowling Champion, Bugz Champion, Makai Grand Prix 2 Champion, White Van Man Champion, Parachute Panic Champion, BlackJack Champion, Stans Ski Jumping Champion, Smaugs Treasure Champion, Sofa Longjump Champion Seamus Fermanagh's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2005
    Location
    Latibulm mali regis in muris.
    Posts
    11,454

    Default Re: Tolkien's Fantasy World Too True To be Fantasy ?

    If you're looking for prime inspiration search the celtic lore of Ireland, Scotland, Wales, the Manx, and some of England's western stretches.

    Influenced by the great conflicts of the early 20th, probably, though magic rings, famous swords, dragons and trolls are classical more than fascist. The Hobbits' collective isolationism and its inability to protect them probably reflects his own experience more than any other.

    And don't discount his buddies down at the pub -- a fairly bright group despite all that English ancestry.

    Seamus
    "The only way that has ever been discovered to have a lot of people cooperate together voluntarily is through the free market. And that's why it's so essential to preserving individual freedom.” -- Milton Friedman

    "The urge to save humanity is almost always a false front for the urge to rule." -- H. L. Mencken

  5. #5
    Scruffy Looking Nerf Herder Member Steppe Merc's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2004
    Location
    New Jersey, USA
    Posts
    7,907

    Default Re: Tolkien's Fantasy World Too True To be Fantasy ?

    Riders of Rohan are essentially Vikings on horses (Rus, I suppose). I know Tolkein was a proffesors of Norse and Saxon mytholgy and language.

    Gondorians are a bit like late Romans, with really only one city, and only their past to keep them going.

    "But if you should fall you fall alone,
    If you should stand then who's to guide you?
    If I knew the way I would take you home."
    Grateful Dead, "Ripple"

  6. #6
    Senior Member Senior Member econ21's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2002
    Posts
    9,651

    Default Re: Tolkien's Fantasy World Too True To be Fantasy ?

    There's a sort of affection for a fading rural England in some of the world - Saruman is ripping up trees to fuel his ironworks while the Shire could be any idealised English Home County.

    It also seemed to me - not least from watching the films - was that the core message of the Lord of the Rings was the need to bravely fight evil. That message would seem very much of its time for an Englishman living in the shadow of two world wars.

  7. #7
    American since 2012 Senior Member AntiochusIII's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2005
    Location
    Lalaland
    Posts
    3,125

    Default Re: Tolkien's Fantasy World Too True To be Fantasy ?

    Viewing from a pessimistic point of view, Tolkien's work can be recognize as racism, as well. With the "evils" in the "wild and unexplored lands of the East" or the Haradrim representing...others...

    However, it is pointless, even stupid, to accuse Tolkien of racism, considering the age he lived in.

    One would think Elendil's two kingdoms (Arnor and Gondor) are representatives of the two Roman empires.

    Shire itself represents Tolkien's ideal "rural Britain." Carefree, ignorant, happy, fertile, but with hidden strength.

    The lost Numenor is recognized by many (including Tolkien himself) as an Atlantis of Middle Earth.
    Last edited by AntiochusIII; 09-05-2005 at 01:49.

  8. #8
    "'elp! I'm bein' repressed!" Senior Member Aenlic's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2005
    Location
    The live music capital of the world.
    Posts
    1,583

    Default Re: Tolkien's Fantasy World Too True To be Fantasy ?

    Tolkien was an admitted anti-semite. It doesn't get talked about much because his works sort of overshadow his negative side. No one is perfect.

    His love for and feeling of loss for the English countryside is real. He talked about it quite a bit in his later letters. He grew up in the West Midlands, in a little village just south of Birmingham. So he was exposed to the rampant industrial growth of Birmingham, as well as the rural life of the small villages and farms there. I think that juxtaposition, combined with the horrors of WWI (nearly every friend he had from school died in WWI) created the scene in his mind that became the backdrop of his written world. He composed most of what was later published as the "Lost Tales" while recovering from trench fever for the last two years of the war.
    "Dee dee dee!" - Annoymous (the "differently challenged" and much funnier twin of Anonymous)

  9. #9

    Default Re: Tolkien's Fantasy World Too True To be Fantasy ?

    Tolkien was an admitted anti-semite. It doesn't get talked about much because his works sort of overshadow his negative side. No one is perfect.
    Hehe, its amazing what can be forgiven when you like the finished product.

    I never understood the bid deal about the Lord of the Rings books. Pretty standard "quest" novels.. nothing particularly great about any of them in my opinion. Its a motif thats been done countless times. I think Star Wars did it much better. (And the movies were just stupid..)

  10. #10
    Ambiguous Member Byzantine Prince's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2003
    Location
    Canada
    Posts
    4,334

    Default Re: Tolkien's Fantasy World Too True To be Fantasy ?

    Fiction is always based on some fact. Even fantasy fiction.

    I hate Star Wars. LOTR rewls!

  11. #11
    Mystic Bard Member Soulforged's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2005
    Location
    Another Skald
    Posts
    2,138

    Default Re: Tolkien's Fantasy World Too True To be Fantasy ?

    If i'm correct the hobbits were based on reality. The inspiration came from the tipical englishman of the period, at least that's what he said.
    Born On The Flames

  12. #12
    Probably Drunk Member Reverend Joe's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2005
    Location
    Up on Cripple Creek
    Posts
    4,647

    Default Re: Tolkien's Fantasy World Too True To be Fantasy ?

    PanzerJaeger- The distinctive factor in Lord of the Rings is the mythos and educated history behind them, not to mention excellent writing (except for the 5th book; it gets kinda thick around then.) Tolkien created an entire history behind the books, albeit inadvertantly (it's a long story)- and it is this entire backdrop that really makes the books stand out against the other quest/fantasy books of the time.

    i never read the Star Wars books- and I had no motivation to, not after seeing the first 3 movies (meaning the early ones, not the ones that just came out. I hate having to explain that.)
    Last edited by Reverend Joe; 09-05-2005 at 04:11.

  13. #13
    Master of useless knowledge Senior Member Kitten Shooting Champion, Eskiv Champion Ironside's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2003
    Location
    Sweden
    Posts
    4,902

    Default Re: Tolkien's Fantasy World Too True To be Fantasy ?

    Quote Originally Posted by LeftEyeNine
    There are many rumors J.R.R. Tolkien's Middle Earth being inspired by the real world. It is something impossible for a writer not to be effected by his/her reality but even every race is assigned to a real one by some people. Although I heard that Tolkien had denied the reality basis of his fantasy world, there are certain things you easily can relate to the reality.

    Any info's / comments ?
    Many of the stories in Silmarillon were found in the Lost Tales, were it was quite obvoius that the intent was that it had happened in England for a long time ago.
    We are all aware that the senses can be deceived, the eyes fooled. But how can we be sure our senses are not being deceived at any particular time, or even all the time? Might I just be a brain in a tank somewhere, tricked all my life into believing in the events of this world by some insane computer? And does my life gain or lose meaning based on my reaction to such solipsism?

    Project PYRRHO, Specimen 46, Vat 7
    Activity Recorded M.Y. 2302.22467
    TERMINATION OF SPECIMEN ADVISED

  14. #14
    Member Member Del Arroyo's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2004
    Location
    noyb
    Posts
    1,009

    Post Re: Tolkien's Fantasy World Too True To be Fantasy ?

    The Tolkien stories, IMO are most definitely allegorical.

    The books are all about a struggle against the industrial revolution. It is clear to me from reading his books that he feels the dehumanizing elements of industrialization, and the low value of human life in "ant-like eastern races" represent the epitome of evil. That if we didn't wake up and fight back, crookedly-learned wisemen and their imported Chinese drones would turn the world into a smoking, filthy, industrial hell.

    (It is also evident that while he in LOTR good triumphs, Tolkien believed the evils of industrialism to be damned near and probably totally unstoppable. Note the seductive evil power of the One Ring. If you eschew industrialism's power, you are powerless to fight it, but if you fight industrialism with industrialism, you will merely be consumed and assimilated into the black night of hell to come. In LOTR the only way to stop it was through trust in one small, pure-hearted Hobbit sent on an illogical and improbable mission-- but in the Real World there are no Cracks of Doom.)

    At least that's my take on his message. Not saying I really agree with it, by the way. But if you consider his experiences, he had a valid viewpoint, and LOTR is a good piece of fiction, regardless.

    DA

    P.S.: As far as literary merit, I actually liked The Hobbit a bit better. LOTR is too dense, and has too much background, if we're talking straight literature. Though obviously it's those aspects that give it its niche.

  15. #15
    Chief Sniffer Senior Member ichi's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2003
    Posts
    3,132

    Default Re: Tolkien's Fantasy World Too True To be Fantasy ?

    Some concepts are universal to the human experience. The same issues of valor, domination, heroism, and the struggle between 'good' and 'evil' found in the trilogy are part of world history.

    One of the best works in all of literature, BTW.

    ichi
    Stay Calm, Be Alert, Think Clearly, Act Decisively

    CoH

  16. #16

    Default Re: Tolkien's Fantasy World Too True To be Fantasy ?

    As much as I hate to say it I have to agree with PJ here.

    While the books are good they are by no means the best, I know he must have put a lot of effort into them but so have many other fantasy writers, like George RR Martin, Steven Erikson and Robert Jordan, and some of them have come up with much more intricate, absorbing worlds in my opinion.

    Also trying to draw parallels with the real world is like pissing in the wind, pointless and the odds are you'll just make a mess , no-one knows or will ever know as he's dead. It's a pet peave of mine when you see people trying to give deeper meanings to things, like dirty bed sheets that some call art, and all they do is end up sounding pompous, slightly foolish and very annoying, not that any of you are like that

  17. #17
    Boy's Guard Senior Member LeftEyeNine's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2003
    Location
    Yozgat
    Posts
    5,168

    Default Re: Tolkien's Fantasy World Too True To be Fantasy ?

    Well, LOTR fiction was the first one that was a seriously fantasy story, wasn't it ?

    The common imaginary races like Elves, Orcs and so on are brought to life by Tolkien, aren't they ?

    That's what I hear from the fans of Tolkien. And if that's true, at least he deserves credit for creation that lasts for a long time and usually used.

    The font style of the Elvish (there were two languages, I do not remember the particular name right now) is said to be inspired by the Arabic. And in newspapers, about a month ago or so, some British journalists (I think 3 of them) were answering questions from the readers. And some claimed that the Orc race was inspired by Turks.
    Strange that we usually get "roasted" now we are claimed by some to be tasting worse than rubber.. Orc flesh? Yuck !

  18. #18
    Boy's Guard Senior Member LeftEyeNine's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2003
    Location
    Yozgat
    Posts
    5,168

    Default Re: Tolkien's Fantasy World Too True To be Fantasy ?

    Not the world's best author, perhaps. But the Wright Brothers were certainly not the world's best pilots, either.
    That summarizes Tolkien's fame. Excellent..

  19. #19
    Member Member Spetulhu's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2002
    Location
    Finland
    Posts
    818

    Default Re: Tolkien's Fantasy World Too True To be Fantasy ?

    Quote Originally Posted by Gelatinous Cube
    As Panzer said, the books are pretty sub-par compared to some of today's greater fantasy works. Wheel of Time, for example.
    Jordan needs to get a real editor instead of going on and on and on and on...
    If you're fighting fair you've made a miscalculation.

  20. #20

    Default Re: Tolkien's Fantasy World Too True To be Fantasy ?

    Quote Originally Posted by Spetulhu
    Jordan needs to get a real editor instead of going on and on and on and on...
    Very true, what we on now, 11 books and counting? I don't think he's got a clue about where he's going, I'm sure it was originally supposed to be 10 books with number nine billed as the penultimate. I'm seriously considering giving up on his series

  21. #21
    Senior Member Senior Member Ser Clegane's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2003
    Location
    Escaped from the pagodas
    Posts
    6,606

    Default Re: Tolkien's Fantasy World Too True To be Fantasy ?

    Quote Originally Posted by Ja'chyra
    I'm seriously considering giving up on his series
    I did so after number 8 when it became increasingly clear to me that the story lost any pace - and as Jordan's writing style is far from stellar, there was not much left to enjoy after the plot stalled...

  22. #22

    Default Re: Tolkien's Fantasy World Too True To be Fantasy ?

    one of my issues with the conventions of fantasy is that in every major work, the freedom-loving chivalric people with knights are always in the west, always bounded by a great western ocean, the 'boundless hordes' and darker skinned peoples are always in the east/south, the viking-esque peoples are always in the north. the steppe peoples are always in the east etc. which i just find silly.
    indeed

  23. #23
    A very, very Senior Member Adrian II's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2004
    Location
    The Netherlands
    Posts
    9,748

    Default Re: Tolkien's Fantasy World Too True To be Fantasy ?

    Quote Originally Posted by nokhor
    one of my issues with the conventions of fantasy is that in every major work, the freedom-loving chivalric people with knights are always in the west, always bounded by a great western ocean, the 'boundless hordes' and darker skinned peoples are always in the east/south, the viking-esque peoples are always in the north. the steppe peoples are always in the east etc. which i just find silly.
    That is why I find nearly all fantasy so utterly boring. It isn't fantasy at all, just a watered-down version of some mediocre writer's idea of reality. Every dwarf, every robot, every elf is another testimony to the author's lack of talent and imagination.

    Y'all may hang me now.
    The bloody trouble is we are only alive when we’re half dead trying to get a paragraph right. - Paul Scott

  24. #24
    Member Member Azi Tohak's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2005
    Location
    Smallville USA.
    Posts
    971

    Default Re: Tolkien's Fantasy World Too True To be Fantasy ?

    Maybe he's not as exciting as some modern writers, but he was the first to create a fantasy world. I think GC is right about his skills.

    I've read his letter about how he despises allegory, and I must say I'm thrilled by it I hate allegory too, and sure, while he had to have taken some of his own experiences and placed them in the book (WWI is too important to ignore), they aren't supposed to be 'true'. Their books and enjoy them (or hate them, whatever) as such.

    Azi
    "If you don't want to work, become a reporter. That awful power, the public opinion of the nation, was created by a horde of self-complacent simpletons who failed at ditch digging and shoemaking and fetched up journalism on their way to the poorhouse."
    Mark Twain 1881

  25. #25
    Saupreuss Member Stefan the Berserker's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2002
    Location
    Baal / Rhineprovince
    Posts
    964

    Default Re: Tolkien's Fantasy World Too True To be Fantasy ?

    Quote Originally Posted by Steppe Merc
    Riders of Rohan are essentially Vikings on horses (Rus, I suppose). I know Tolkein was a proffesors of Norse and Saxon mytholgy and language.

    Gondorians are a bit like late Romans, with really only one city, and only their past to keep them going.
    Mostly. Tolkien was proffesor of Norse mytholgy and Linguistics.

    The official claim of Tolkien was that he admired the celtic and germanic mythology and wanted to create an "English mythology" since his people, in his viewpoint, would not obtain an own mythology.

    However they historically shared the norse mythology (Saxons) , during the both worldwars the English developed to denie their roots on the Continent since this would create a connection with their Enemy (Germans).

    He wanted to create a mostly realistic mythology, so he mixed Elements of:

    Celtic Mythology
    Norse/Germanic Mythology
    Dark Age European History
    The old Testament/ The holy Bible

    Which were sensefully factors which could have influenced he grew of an "English mythology".

    So you will find an equivalent of Noah, with Elendil sailing with fellows to middlearth when Numenor sinks. Aswell as the Hamites-Haradrim, Odin-Gandalf or Fomorii-Orks.

    However who is interessted in this should prefer the Book, since the Films are good but they change the shape of many aspects.

  26. #26
    Scruffy Looking Nerf Herder Member Steppe Merc's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2004
    Location
    New Jersey, USA
    Posts
    7,907

    Default Re: Tolkien's Fantasy World Too True To be Fantasy ?

    The books are great, and I love em. I like the newer series like Wheel of Time and GRR Martin's series, whatever it's called. But I guess it's sort of like the Beatles, as good as other bands, the Beatles were the first, so they're the best.
    The films are good, and while they do change stuff, it still seems the same world and story.

    And WOT is a bit too long. It needs less of those scheming Aes Sedai, and more Borderlanders (preferably Saladean) versus Trollocs.
    But I'm gonna read them all. Though Jordan could take hints from Martin when it comes to getting to the point.

    edit: Stefan, thanks for correcting me, I knew it was Norse, but I wasn't sure what else he studied.

    "But if you should fall you fall alone,
    If you should stand then who's to guide you?
    If I knew the way I would take you home."
    Grateful Dead, "Ripple"

  27. #27
    Senior Member Senior Member English assassin's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2004
    Location
    London, innit
    Posts
    3,734

    Default Re: Tolkien's Fantasy World Too True To be Fantasy ?

    If you ask me Tolkien is a grossly sub-par reworking of bits of Norse myth and that's it. Poems in Elvish, give me a break.

    The Hobbits are obviously English though. Evidence:

    (1) they like beer and specifically pubs (OK, they could be Scottish or Irish as well on that basis. But no one else)

    (2) they like books full of things they already know, set out fair and square, with no contradictions. That rules out the Celts who are a notoriously brainy if highly strung bunch, therefore by a process of elimination Hobbits are English.

    Quite why Tolkien felt the country needed a mythology in which it was depicted as irritating little midgets I do not know, in the same way I have some difficulty in seeing LOTR as an improvement on Beowulf. Obviously the world of fantasy must remain closed to me...
    "The only thing I've gotten out of this thread is that Navaros is claiming that Satan gave Man meat. Awesome." Gorebag

  28. #28
    Resident Northern Irishman Member ShadesPanther's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2003
    Location
    Northern Ireland
    Posts
    1,616

    Default Re: Tolkien's Fantasy World Too True To be Fantasy ?

    There was a website I read that was full of the mythology and all kinds of things regarding middle Earth. I'll see if I can find it

    "A man may fight for many things: his country, his principles, his friends, the glistening tear on the cheek of a golden child. But personally, I'd mudwrestle my own mother for a ton of cash, an amusing clock and a stack of French porn."
    - Edmund Blackadder

  29. #29
    zombologist Senior Member doc_bean's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2004
    Location
    Riding Shai-Hulud
    Posts
    5,346

    Default Re: Tolkien's Fantasy World Too True To be Fantasy ?

    I really don't understand how people can say Jordan is a better writer than Tolkien, all his male and all his female characters are the same, his pacing is terrible and most of the book(s) are filled with silly detours. What happened at the end of book 3 was known to happen by the end of book 2 ! Every person in power is female and all males seem to be afraid of women (yeah, realistic for a medieval setting).

    Still the worst fantasy I ever read (I swear I read better videogame fanfiction than that) was the first book in the Sword of Truth series by Terry Goodkind, it has to be read to be believed, but I won't recommend doing that to anyone.

    The best fantasy book, imho, is Magician by Feist. It manages to be fun and entertaining throughout, and has very likable characters. His other work isn't at the same level, but this quite fun to read.

    I do agree with AdrianII though, the fantasy genre is formulatic (sp?) and, taken as a whole, rather boring and predictable. I consider it pulp instead of literature. But pulp can be entertaining when you're in the right mood.
    Yes, Iraq is peaceful. Go to sleep now. - Adrian II

  30. #30
    American since 2012 Senior Member AntiochusIII's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2005
    Location
    Lalaland
    Posts
    3,125

    Default Re: Tolkien's Fantasy World Too True To be Fantasy ?

    But Tolkien is the pioneer of the genre, is he not? I believe in games, books, and all sorts of fantasy stuff in the world carries resemblance to Tolkien's Middle Earth. Tolkien's elves influenced a lot of elven species. Even Morrowind's elves are similar to his. So it may be that the fantasy genre copies his works too many times that the original (more-or-less) becomes unoriginal in modern readers' minds.

    At least the dragons are purely evil here and the "knights who fought the dragons" are dwarven armed forces, and that Rohan knights were by no means Arthurian knights (as in literature), but are just heavy "Sarmatian" horsemen with devastating charges. Oh, and no Medieval castles, either, but rather Gondorian strongholds.
    Last edited by AntiochusIII; 09-05-2005 at 18:43.

Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  
Single Sign On provided by vBSSO