Federal judge declares Pledge unconstitutional

[Proletariat]

5) Again the pledge would only be unconstitutional if your forced to say it.

Bravo. Precisely what I tried but failed miserably to get out yesterday.

The thread can pretty much be locked now.

[Gawain of Orkeny]

Again the pledge would only be unconstitutional if your forced to say it.

And this is why his ruling will definetly be overturned. All those of you who want it gone dont stand a chance. Again the mention of God in no way establishes a religion. Belief in god is not a religion and therefore the mention of god cannot be seen as establishing a religion.

On the matter of them adding this becaiuse of the cold war. It wasnt just symbolic. We then truly believed we were a christain nation and that the Russians were doomed and bad because of their lack of belief. Also lost in this little debate is the fact the the US indeed was one nation formed under god from the get go.