How is phalanx vs maniple in EB?

[Divinus Arma]

I disagree, I'd use skirmish units out front...if only to soak up the Pila from the Romans that way I wouldnt lose any of my precious, precious Phalangites.

Why not both? Deploy in front until the first volley is thron, then have them rush back through the phalangites to safety. Best way is to have you phalanx with spears up until the skirmishers are past, then drop points just before those nasty romans charge.