Which Scoth is best?

[Beirut]

I killed a bottle (not in one night) of 18 year-old Glenmoranghie for my 40th birthday. Cost me $125. It was very good scotch but probably too good for me. I'm not enough of scotch fanatic to appreciate the subtleties that bottle had. Was still damn fine scotch, though light. I prefer, if I have to drink Scotch, Lagavulin. That stuff has body.

I much, much prefer bourbon. Booker's Best (from Jim Beam) is the top of the line in that department. From a single keg straight into the bottle, no additives or perversions of any kind. It's the only single barrel, straight keg bourbon there is. Most bottles runabout 126 proof and $80Can. Hard to find too. Wild Turkey is the best readily available bourbon. The 12 year-old Turkey is pure gold.

I tried a shot of single barrel Jack Daniel's last weekend and didn't like it at all. Smoky aftertaste really hits hard. Not peaty/smoky like scotch, I mean smoke-smoky. Almost unpleasent

[Strike For The South]

I much, much prefer bourbon. Booker's Best (from Jim Beam) is the top of the line in that department.

YES

I tried a shot of single barrel Jack Daniel's last weekend and didn't like it at all. Smoky aftertaste really hits hard. Not peaty/smoky like scotch, I mean smoke-smoky. Almost unpleasent

NO

[Taffy_is_a_Taff]

what about knob creek?

[Beirut]

what about knob creek?

Knob Creek is very good. I've gone through two or three bottles of Knob Creek and always enjoy it. It's part of a "small batch" collection that's listed here:http://www.smallbatch.com Knob Creek is easy to find here in Canadaland and runs about $40 a bottle.

I've never had the Bakers or the Basil Hayden's, but I'm sure they're tasty.

But after tasting many bourbons, from good to excellent, the Booker's Best remains the, well... the best.

The booze stores here are carrying 16 year-old Bushmills. Definitely getting a bottle of that. $80! Gah! Maybe a Christmas present for myself. Trying to find the 21 year-old Bushmills but having no luck.