I've read here many times swords will badly defeat spears. In my campaign battles they usually do, but now I made about 10 custom battles- CMAA vs. saracen inf/CS (they have the same stats). My swordsmen won only in half of them, the other half looked like this (or worse):



As recommended, I set CMAA in two lines, while AI's saracen inf were in 4 lines, as usual.



The end of the battle

So, do you have simmilar experiences or have I done sth wrong?