I agree with everyone. It's impossible to get a good general. in RTW, it used to be easy to get a good commanding general as you only have to fight couple of battles. It was impossible to get a good managing general, sicne most of the time if you stick him in cities, you'd get so many bad traits, it cancels out anything. Now, you can't even gain commanding stars anymore because your general rebels.

I wonder if your faction heir rebels?