Unfortunately, there are few really good books on the Celts. Most either tend to be the more heavy scholarly type and thus focus either on specifics or broad generalities; usually concentrating on the material culture (archeology, and by association anthropology), or the're just regurgitated and simplified candy. Few cover the issue in a holistic or exhaustive manner (ie history married with archeology etc). To get a good understanding, one is forced to read through just about everything written on the subject and put the pieces together. A very time consuming process...but if one has the interest...Originally Posted by Julian the Apostrophe
![]()
If none bet me to it, I hope one day to write a book / s to see if I can better provide a more exhaustive account of these peoples.
Yer Collis wrote 'Origins, Myths and Inventions'. He also wrote 'Oppida' in 84 and other works on the Iron Age..much of which he's included in his 'Origins, Myths and Inventions' book.Originally Posted by Ranika
There's some very good info in Collins 'Origins..' but I generally wasn't a huge fan. He never really clearly defines his hypothesis. He raises allot on interesting points which appear on face value to challenge other establish understandings but fails to actually explore that data and provide a clear interpretation himself. As such one tends to come to the conclusion that he has tended to sensationalise and focus on the data that lie outside the mean of normal findings... to focus on the 'statistical outliers'. Imho, this modes operandi is not inducive to one gaining a holistic picture of the data at hand. An interesting read nonetheless.
Cunliffe is exceptional with the material culture but a little weaker on the history. Powell is one of the venerated pioneers of much of our current Celtic study. His works however lack some of the more recent data.
Yer, Ellis is good value. If your looking for a more simple / easy to read history of the celts / various tribes, Daithi O' Hogan’s "The Celts, A History" is good. If you’re wanting to start a study on the Celts, I’d definitely start with O’ Hogan.Originally Posted by NeonGod
Bookmarks