RTR Light MP campaign mod discussion....

[hellenes]

As the participants in Myrdaal's MP campaign will know me and Destroyer of Hope are making a Light Version of RTR 6.2 specifically balanced and tuned for a MP campaign with the fewest preset/real world rules possible.
The mod will feature unit skins/models/UI cards from RTR 6.2 replacing every unit in the game where apropriate.
No maijor alteration will be done as far as unit stats are concerned.
The map stays vanilla 100%
this mod will be for RTW 1.3
Egypt will be "Ptolemaised" aka made into a sensible faction instead of some Egyptiolover's sick imagination.
Rome will be unified since there is no purpose for a Senate and there is no artificial need for late challnge having the 3 Roman kingdoms and its not SP.
All faction units will be restricted to their starting homeland cities and the cities that they influenced/conquered historically to avoid blitzkrieg and exploit rushing.
Each faction unit will have a unique upkeep/initial cost depending on unit's:
-Factions economic condition (Egypt rich-expensive units, Numidia poor-cheap units)
-Stats
-How effective the unit is (cavalry stacking up, horse archers design power, chariots, Elephants) eg Horse archer stats are low but their effectivness is very high.
-Faction's developing potential (eg, barbarians cant develope trade and agriculture same as the Greeks or the Easterns).
These are so far the changes. The aim was to keep it as closer to vanilla as possible.
Now TO ALL MP CAMPAIGN PARTICIPANTS!!
we have some cases of units that need to be decided whether they must GO or be tolerated like a 12 years' old's caprice:

Dogs:

Pros- Used in battles
- Give a more distinctive prluralistic feeling to the barbarians
- Are "fun" *SUBJECTIVE*

Cons- Used only in VERY scarce battles, very rarely
- Regenerate in a VERY unbalanced way
- Unattackable (just in case we get the battles to work)
- Romans use them which makes them even more overpowered (the romans)

Screeching Women:

Pros- Followed men on the battlefield
- Give a more distinctive prluralistic feeling to the Germans
- Are "fun" *SUBJECTIVE*

Cons- Used only in VERY scarce battles, very rarely
- Didnt fight!!!
- Look VERY stupid *SUBJECTIVE*
- Unaccurate cheerleaders in mini skirts from the 70's holding axes like holding male genitalia.

Burning Pigs:

Pros- Used in battles
- Give a more distinctive prluralistic feeling to the game
- Are "fun" *SUBJECTIVE*
- Are one way to outweight elephants

Cons- Used only in ONE battle
- Used with VERY limited success (contrary to the game's depiction)
- Never used after that one battle
- Regenerate in a VERY unbalanced way (not so much as the dogs but still)
- Look VERY stupid *SUBJECTIVE*
- There are other ways to balance elephants

Onagers:

Pros- Used in battles
- Give a more distinctive prluralistic feeling to the game
- Are "fun" *SUBJECTIVE*
- Speed up sieges

Cons- Way out of time frame
- Grossly unbalanced patriot rockets (proof-No art online games)
- Historically inaccurate even by 1st Cetury ad standards
- Even if balanced derive from the classical NOT dominated by artillery battlefield

Scythian Noble Women/Virgin Headhunters:

Pros- Fought alongside men on the battlefield
- Give a more distinctive prluralistic feeling to the Scythians
- Are "fun" *SUBJECTIVE*

Cons- Used only in VERY small numbers compared to the men
- Engine limitations forbid their impelentation as all unit must look the same (except maybe for standard bearers/officers)
- Historically innaccurate look: Same inaccurate cheerleaders in mini skirts from the 70's holding axes like holding male genitalia just with a different skin.
- Look VERY stupid *SUBJECTIVE*

Headhurlers

Pros- The Celts collected heads
- Give a more distinctive prluralistic feeling to the Britons
- Are "fun" *SUBJECTIVE*

Cons- The Celts would NEVER throw away a trophy of magical importance and honour.
- Generally a VERY medievalistic idea out of the timeframe.
- Look VERY stupid *SUBJECTIVE*

Arcani

Pros- The Romans had a special force of assasins
- Like MTW Hashishins the story continues
- Are "fun" ninjas/nazgul *SUBJECTIVE*

Cons- The assasins were THAT ASSASINS not participating in ANY battle.
- Look like VERY stupid sadomazochists *SUBJECTIVE*
- Offer nothing more than a small unit with 2 HP on the battlefield

Gladiators

Pros- Spartacus, revolt, gladiators...
- Are "fun" and cause Ive watched Russel Crow 12345 times on dvd *SUBJECTIVE*
- Can be used in slave revolutions.

Cons- Spartacus' gladiators fought in looted from the dead Romans weaponry not with Gladiator gear which is USLESS for mass field battles.
- Look VERY stupid *SUBJECTIVE*
- Offer nothing more than a small unit with 2 HP on the battlefield
- Engine limitations on changing gear and looting it from the enemy (even if we got them as gladiators at the beggining)

Bull Warriors

Pros- Spanish unit line if quite poor so...
- Are "fun" *SUBJECTIVE*

Cons- Look VERY stupid *SUBJECTIVE*
- Pure FANTASY
- Plenty of historical units on hand to replace

Scythian/German Axemen

Pros- Scythian/German unit line if quite poor so...
- Are "fun" *SUBJECTIVE*
- They might have had such a unit...

Cons- Look VERY stupid *SUBJECTIVE*
- Pure FANTASY
- Plenty of historical units on hand to replace
- They might have had Jedi knights, Pokemon, and Buffy the Vampireslayer

Druids

Pros- Druids fought in battles
- Are "fun" *SUBJECTIVE*
- Give a more distinctive prluralistic feeling to the Barbarians

Cons- Look VERY stupid *SUBJECTIVE*
- They didnt fight with Communist gear neither were chating to support the troops.
- Plenty of historical units on hand to replace
- Might be ONLY used as officers.
- Not necessary

Please cast your vote by stating for each unit your opinion.

The list:
Dogs
Stay
GO!! +1+1+1+1+1+1

Screeching Women
Stay+1+1
GO!!+1+1+1+1

Burning Pigs
Stay+1+1
GO!! +1+1+1+1

Onagers
Stay+1+1+1
GO!!+1+1+1

Scythian Noble Women/Virgin Headhunters
Stay +1+1
GO!!+1+1+1+1

Headhurlers
Stay+1+1+1
GO!!+1+1+1

Arcani
Stay+1
GO!!+1+1+1+1+1

Gladiators
Stay+1+1+1+1
GO!!+1+1

Bull Warriors
Stay+1+1
GO!!+1+1+1+1

Scythian/German Axemen
Stay+1
GO!!+1+1+1+1+1

Druids
Stay+1
GO!!+1+1+1+1+1

Hellenes

Edit:Updated the choices
Stating your reasons for each choice wouldnt harm...
Edit2: Votes reverted to the units go/stay choice fo each unit!!!
PLEASE STATE DELETE OR STAY FOR EACH UNIT!!
Edit3: Updated.
Edit4: Updated
PLEASE STATE STAY OR GO NEXT TO EACH UNIT!!!!!!!!!