You're thinking too hard. The good and the bad, heaven and hell are all a one-ness. If you are faithful to God and follow His laws you will be rewarded, both here and in the hereafter. If you scorn Him and lead an amoral and a careless life, you will reap the consequences, both now and later.

To even contemplate the nature of Free Will, or to wonder whether God looks like a Man or a Frog, is simply over-thinking the Question.

DA