
Originally Posted by
Rosacrux redux
Usually, that's the way killing is conducted anyway. And if we take out the scope from our argument and just say "since they both killed intentionally they are equally bad", then we have to include every mass murderer in history at the same level. Not really every mass murderer only, every dictator is guilty for killing intentionally a large number of people. So, Hitler was no worst than Stalin, Mao, Pinochet, Pol Pot, Papadoc, Batista, Franko, Sadham, Talaat Pasha, Papadopoulos, Kemal and countless other dictators and "dictators", right?
Not to mention that we should include every military leader as well, right? And every revolution leader too. And we might even include some serial killers, for good measure, huh?
Not quite, what we need is Scope and Context. Otherwise we are missing the whole point.
Bookmarks