Results 1 to 30 of 92

Thread: Any new spartan unit in the making?

Hybrid View

Previous Post Previous Post   Next Post Next Post
  1. #1
    Member Member paullus's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2005
    Location
    always in places where its HOT
    Posts
    11,904

    Default Re: Any new spartan unit in the making?

    Can you really say "what exactly is historical"? We're dealing with several hundred years of pretty significant changes--political, social, economic and presumably military. Historically, the elite of the equals in 272 probably looked different from the elites in 222, and so on. Even within the soldiers in 272, some of the soldiers probably had fancier cuirasses than others. And unless you know of some Hellenistic period greaves or tomb paintings or reliefs or cuirasses from Sparta, then its all pretty speculative anyway.

    And may I suggest being willing to make a small stretch by including "beauty" as a factor in discerning reasonability/accuracy, especially in a speculative case like this one.
    "The mere statement of fact, though it may excite our interest, is of no benefit to us, but when the knowledge of the cause is added, then the study of history becomes fruitful." -Polybios


  2. #2

    Default Re: Any new spartan unit in the making?

    My thoughts pretty much paullus. We are going to err, of course, in our depiction. Too many variables to account for especially given the restrictions of our game engine. But I'm willing to err a little more on the side of having more elaborate gear than erring too much on the other side (plus, I like countering the general idea most folks have of the artistically-deprived Spartans, which isn't the case).

    I would note that any elaborate metalwork would probably have come from outside of Lakonia at this time though. I haven't mentioned this internally yet, but today I've been reading a little more about "Lakonian artistic production and the problem of spartan austerity". Lakonian metalwork itself really did suffer at this point in their history (especially as compared to the boom in the sixth century), but as these men have mostly served as mercs, much of their armor was acquired outside of Lakonia.

  3. #3
    Devout occultist Member Forgus's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2004
    Location
    Aquincum, Pannonia Inferior Ak-Ink, Eravacouw
    Posts
    1,834

    Default Re: Any new spartan unit in the making?

    Continuing the internal struggle outside - though I sworn to remain silent -
    To me a metal cuirass - well probably, fancy graves? - maybe. Helm fit for a king - hmmm, if you say so. But these together? Hardly. Pompous enough for a monach in Persia...

  4. #4

    Default Re: Any new spartan unit in the making?

    From what I've heard, one of those three will also be simplified Forgus, in addition to the cloak. So maybe we can all come to an agreement, or at least closer to one. I'm anxiously awaiting the screenshots. I do think a little discussion out here is a good thing.

  5. #5
    Member Member paullus's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2005
    Location
    always in places where its HOT
    Posts
    11,904

    Default Re: Any new spartan unit in the making?

    As far as luxuries, you could look at it this way: many of these guys (may) have served in the armies of Seleukus or Ptolemy etc, and been well paid. In the case of Ptolemy especially, they could very well have been paid the money to afford or even straight-up given very nice equipment. How do you think the first couple of Ptolemy's (nearly) blew the bank? I mean, I haven't seen the concepts you guys are throwing around, but a well-accoutred (though not gaudy) soldier seems pretty reasonable.

    And what are you thinking for the shields? A hoplon I hope, but what would you put on it?
    And just what did you mean by "a helm fit for a king"?
    Thanks!
    "The mere statement of fact, though it may excite our interest, is of no benefit to us, but when the knowledge of the cause is added, then the study of history becomes fruitful." -Polybios


  6. #6
    Not Just A Name; A Way Of Life Member Sarcasm's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2005
    Location
    Olissipo, Lusitania
    Posts
    3,744

    Default Re: Any new spartan unit in the making?

    Quote Originally Posted by paullus
    As far as luxuries, you could look at it this way: many of these guys (may) have served in the armies of Seleukus or Ptolemy etc, and been well paid. In the case of Ptolemy especially, they could very well have been paid the money to afford or even straight-up given very nice equipment. How do you think the first couple of Ptolemy's (nearly) blew the bank? I mean, I haven't seen the concepts you guys are throwing around, but a well-accoutred (though not gaudy) soldier seems pretty reasonable.

    And what are you thinking for the shields? A hoplon I hope, but what would you put on it?
    And just what did you mean by "a helm fit for a king"?
    Thanks!
    The first spartan skin used a muscle cuirass with ornate stomach, an ornate pilos helmet and very ornate greaves as well, all bronze.

    It wore a red tunic underneath, and a *very* beatifull cloak on top of everything.

    As armament it carried an hoplon with bronze sheeting and traditional lambda, plus a spear.

    ****************

    As for my personal opinion, a combat unit could not have possibly have that kind of luxury. Perhaps a close bodyguard of a few dozen men, but that's all.

    I believe even as mercenaries they wouldn't be able to afford everything quite like that (afterall, our mistophoroi aren't even equipped with bronze). The most attested piece is surely the helmet, and that may stay in its current form, but the other things should be simplified.
    Last edited by Sarcasm; 04-20-2006 at 16:21.



    We are all in the gutter, but some of us are looking at the stars

    -- Oscar Wilde

  7. #7
    Not Just A Name; A Way Of Life Member Sarcasm's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2005
    Location
    Olissipo, Lusitania
    Posts
    3,744

    Default Re: Any new spartan unit in the making?

    EDIT: Weird double post, one with an edit and one without...
    Last edited by Sarcasm; 04-20-2006 at 16:11.



    We are all in the gutter, but some of us are looking at the stars

    -- Oscar Wilde

  8. #8
    Member Member Kampfduck's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2005
    Location
    Mederiacum
    Posts
    40

    Default Re: Any new spartan unit in the making?

    any news about these guys? will they be implanted in version 0.8?

    cheers

  9. #9
    Now sporting a classic avatar! Member fallen851's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2005
    Posts
    799

    Default Re: Any new spartan unit in the making?

    I'll be happy with any Spartan that doesn't have a red cloak on.

    Which reminds me, who did the research for CA on this period?

    The Spartans never wore their red cloaks in combat!
    "It's true that when it's looked at isolated, Rome II is a good game... but every time I sit down to play it, every battle, through every turn, I see how Rome I was better. Not unanimously, but ultimately." - Dr. Sane

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L6eaBtzqqFA#t=1h15m33s

  10. #10
    Member Member Avicenna's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2006
    Location
    Terra, Solar System, Orion Arm, Milky Way, Local Group, Virgo Supercluster, somewhere in this universe.
    Posts
    2,746

    Default Re: Any new spartan unit in the making?

    Quote Originally Posted by fallen851
    I'll be happy with any Spartan that doesn't have a red cloak on.

    Which reminds me, who did the research for CA on this period?

    The Spartans never wore their red cloaks in combat!
    I think the Spartans did. I don't think the objective was to have them look terrifying only in front of their allies and subordinates in the camp. They were meant to terrify the opposition.
    Student by day, bacon-eating narwhal by night (specifically midnight)

  11. #11
    Now sporting a classic avatar! Member fallen851's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2005
    Posts
    799

    Default Re: Any new spartan unit in the making?

    Quote Originally Posted by Tiberius
    I think the Spartans did. I don't think the objective was to have them look terrifying only in front of their allies and subordinates in the camp. They were meant to terrify the opposition.
    Great. They did not wear them in combat, they do not have arm holes, so they would have to "peel" the cloak back in combat, meaning it would get in their way and fight them everytime they did anything. Secondly the wind wouldn't do them (or the people behind them) any favors.

    They used the cloaks as blankets at night and for protection from the weather. They did not wear them in combat.

    As John Warry reports on page 47 of Warfare in the Classical World: "The red cloak seen in the illustration was the charateristic Spartan uniform. It was discarded in battle."

    And on page 52 he states: "The enveloping cloak could also serve as a blanket, but it was not worn in battle."

    Twice he quite clearly states the cloak was not worn in battle. I remember reading some other sources repeating the above, I'll find them if necessary, but I thought this was established...

    Sadly it seems the sterotypical image of the Spartan has many people here fooled (much like the sterotypical image of King Arthur with 13th century armor).
    Last edited by fallen851; 08-03-2006 at 21:07.
    "It's true that when it's looked at isolated, Rome II is a good game... but every time I sit down to play it, every battle, through every turn, I see how Rome I was better. Not unanimously, but ultimately." - Dr. Sane

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L6eaBtzqqFA#t=1h15m33s

  12. #12

    Default Re: Any new spartan unit in the making?

    thats john warry's opinion, and im sure he wasnt a spartan

  13. #13
    Member Member Avicenna's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2006
    Location
    Terra, Solar System, Orion Arm, Milky Way, Local Group, Virgo Supercluster, somewhere in this universe.
    Posts
    2,746

    Default Re: Any new spartan unit in the making?

    Quote Originally Posted by fallen851
    Great. They did not wear them in combat, they do not have arm holes, so they would have to "peel" the cloak back in combat, meaning it would get in their way and fight them everytime they did anything. Secondly the wind wouldn't do them (or the people behind them) any favors.

    They used the cloaks as blankets at night and for protection from the weather. They did not wear them in combat.

    As John Warry reports on page 47 of Warfare in the Classical World: "The red cloak seen in the illustration was the charateristic Spartan uniform. It was discarded in battle."

    And on page 52 he states: "The enveloping cloak could also serve as a blanket, but it was not worn in battle."

    Twice he quite clearly states the cloak was not worn in battle. I remember reading some other sources repeating the above, I'll find them if necessary, but I thought this was established...

    Sadly it seems the sterotypical image of the Spartan has many people here fooled (much like the sterotypical image of King Arthur with 13th century armor).
    ... and he obviously has a greater knowledge of the Spartans than the Greek historians? I forgot who it was, since my books are back at school.

    The cloak was over one of the shoulders (left, I believe) and then under the other, the right one, so it wouldn't get in the way of the arm with the spear held in its hand.

    I really don't think that my exam course will be less reliable than your reading of a British or American book.

    Anyway, Lykourgos said that the cloak served to make handsome men more so and ugly men more terrifying. Unless they can telepathically reach their opponents, this shows that they wore them into battle to instill fear into their opponents.
    Last edited by Avicenna; 08-04-2006 at 02:51.
    Student by day, bacon-eating narwhal by night (specifically midnight)

  14. #14
    MOΛΩΝ ΛΑΒΕ Member Idomeneas's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2005
    Location
    The land of the gods
    Posts
    460

    Default Re: Any new spartan unit in the making?

    Quote Originally Posted by Tiberius
    I think the Spartans did. I don't think the objective was to have them look terrifying only in front of their allies and subordinates in the camp. They were meant to terrify the opposition.
    many scholars support that they didnt wore the cloaks in battle. But even if there were not scholars supporting it a simple visit in greece would be enough to prove that there is no possible way to wear a cloak under the summer sun. The armour by itself is enough to exhaust you from heat. Wear a cloak also... you must be crazy..

    I will inform you that even the army helmets are a pain in the ass today in mid summer. In very hot days they issue orders to remove them in guard duty.
    μηνιν αειδε θεα Πηληιαδεω Αχιληοs ουλομενην

  15. #15
    EB Pointless Extras Botherer Member VandalCarthage's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2005
    Posts
    1,813

    Default Re: Any new spartan unit in the making?

    You guys are misunderstanding; our unit doesn't have the full red cloak of Spartan tradition, just a small one.
    "It is an error to divide people into the living and the dead: there are people who are dead-alive, and people who are alive_alive. The dead-alive also write, walk, speak, atc. But they make no mistakes; only machines make no mistakes, and they produce only dead things. The alive-alive are constantly in error, in search, in questions, in torment." - Yevgeny Zamyatin

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  
Single Sign On provided by vBSSO