PC Mode
Org Mobile Site
Forum > Discussion > Monastery (History) >
Thread: Lest We Forget
Incongruous 22:43 04-24-2006
Today is ANZAC day, and I thought a better day than any to discus the disastrous Dardaneles campaign as envisioned by Churchill and the sacrifices made by ANZACS, British French and Turks upon the rugged terrain of Gallipoli.

Disscuss away.

Reply
Alexanderofmacedon 23:01 04-24-2006
Happy ANZAC day?



Reply
Incongruous 00:42 04-25-2006
ANZAC Australia and New Zealand Army Corps earnt fame and recognition during the Gallipoli camaign of 1915 and today is their day of rememberance in NZ, AUS and GB.

Reply
Csargo 01:39 04-25-2006
Yes right after that Campaign Churchill resigned as Navy Minister right? I dont know too much about it except it was disasterous for the British.

Reply
Incongruous 13:19 04-25-2006
Yep Churchill resigned and the commander of the laned forces Sir Ian Hamilton was sacked and replaced by Monro. The British exoected the Turks to simply flee in awe and terror. They did not count upon the proffesionalism and tenacity of the Turks defenting the Dardanelles. Especially those under Mustapha Kamal

Reply
matteus the inbred 13:28 04-25-2006
Tenacious though Turkish resistance was, in country well-suited to defence, I think the campaign was poorly executed and suffered from delays in landing, reinforcing and supplying the troops. In particular, there were incidents of landings being made on the wrong areas and similar, and poor understanding of the terrain. I don't know if it was one of those big 'might-have-beens', as I don't think it detracted from German strength on the Western Front at all, but it could have achieved most of the objectives set out for it had it been done properly.
An examination of it appears in a not-entirely-well-written book called 'Military Blunders' which I own.

All in all, a sad waste of an opportunity for which Churchill rightly took much of the blame.

Reply
Up
Single Sign On provided by vBSSO