The results:

Lucius Amelius - aka DDW - 3 votes (2+1)
Tiberius Coruncanus - aka FLYdude - 7 votes (6+1)
Publius Laevinius - aka shifty157 - 3 votes (1+2)
Quintus - aka econ21 - 11 votes (5+6)

Quintus is duly elected First Consul.

Note: there are 10 bonus votes equal to half avatar influence (rounded up):
econ21+4; shifty157+2; DDW +1; Flydude+1; Ignoramus+2;