I agree with all here: If the diplomacy does not connect with the Campaign AI, then the diplomacy is worthless. And if the campaign AI is poor, then diplomacy is made further worthless.

I regarded RTW diplomacy as a complete failure. I never used it and considered attempts by the AI to engage in diplomacy as an annoyance.

This is promising, but everything hinges on the AI. To play this game, I will have to buy a new computer (since mine just fried). Because of this, I am certainly going to wait for Orgah reviews on AI before I go throw away $1,000.00 on a new computer just to play a TW game. (Since I play nothing else)

At least we can enjoy the orgy of screenies that gamespot provides us.