Gotta have more Mafia [Concluded]

[Ignoramus]

So there is 2/11 chance of us executing a mafia member this turn.

[Silver Rusher]

One Chinese Mafia and one Chinese Godfather left.

Don't forget the serial killer, if there is one (as opposed to a vigilante)

[Sigurd]

I guess nobody is voting yet…
It is understandable as the clues are buried deeply.

What do we have though?
We know that 4 people have been robbed during this game.

DA- was asleep when his house was robbed.
Orb – reported that his house was robbed, because he was out doing nightly business.
Crazed Rabbit – reported that his house was robbed.
Ignoramus – reported that his house was robbed.

Now if we look at this logically maybe the thief is sending us a message here.
DA was in his house the nigh it was robbed.
Orb was out, coming home to a robbed house.
Ignoramus claims he is the prostitute and thus is never home at night.
That means Crazed Rabbit is also out during the night if we should interpret the Thief’s message here.
Maybe doc_bean got a whiff that Crazed rabbit is his major opponent; a Chinese mafia?
Crazed Rabbit was let off the hook last round and I guess it was my fault.
Sorry CR but there is not much to work with here. I believe the Thief is sending us a message here because he knew that Ignoramus had declared himself as the prostitute.

Vote: Crazed Rabbit



If you are not a Mafioso you might be the serial killer.

[Avicenna]

Vote:Crazed Rabbit

[Reenk Roink]

I guess nobody is voting yet…
It is understandable as the clues are buried deeply.

What do we have though?
We know that 4 people have been robbed during this game.

DA- was asleep when his house was robbed.
Orb – reported that his house was robbed, because he was out doing nightly business.
Crazed Rabbit – reported that his house was robbed.
Ignoramus – reported that his house was robbed.

Now if we look at this logically maybe the thief is sending us a message here.
DA was in his house the nigh it was robbed.
Orb was out, coming home to a robbed house.
Ignoramus claims he is the prostitute and thus is never home at night.
That means Crazed Rabbit is also out during the night if we should interpret the Thief’s message here.
Maybe doc_bean got a whiff that Crazed rabbit is his major opponent; a Chinese mafia?
Crazed Rabbit was let off the hook last round and I guess it was my fault.
Sorry CR but there is not much to work with here. I believe the Thief is sending us a message here because he knew that Ignoramus had declared himself as the prostitute.

Vote: Crazed Rabbit



If you are not a Mafioso you might be the serial killer.

This logic supercedes my logic.

Vote: Crazed Rabbit

[Evil_Maniac From Mars]

I guess nobody is voting yet…
It is understandable as the clues are buried deeply.

What do we have though?
We know that 4 people have been robbed during this game.

DA- was asleep when his house was robbed.
Orb – reported that his house was robbed, because he was out doing nightly business.
Crazed Rabbit – reported that his house was robbed.
Ignoramus – reported that his house was robbed.

Now if we look at this logically maybe the thief is sending us a message here.
DA was in his house the nigh it was robbed.
Orb was out, coming home to a robbed house.
Ignoramus claims he is the prostitute and thus is never home at night.
That means Crazed Rabbit is also out during the night if we should interpret the Thief’s message here.
Maybe doc_bean got a whiff that Crazed rabbit is his major opponent; a Chinese mafia?
Crazed Rabbit was let off the hook last round and I guess it was my fault.
Sorry CR but there is not much to work with here. I believe the Thief is sending us a message here because he knew that Ignoramus had declared himself as the prostitute.

Vote: Crazed Rabbit



If you are not a Mafioso you might be the serial killer.

My logic has just been, frankly, PWNED.

Vote: Crazed Rabbit

[Cowhead418]

At this time there is not much to go on (surprisingly), though doc_bean going after Crazed Rabbit is interesting. Only one way to find out his true identity. Vote: Crazed Rabbit.

[Ignoramus]

Vote: Crazed Rabbit.

[Crazed Rabbit]

Crap. I come back and everyone's voting for me.

It looks like the end for me, so I'm confessing.

I'm not Chinese mafia. I'm the serial killer. The last three times I killed noone because I attacked two people who were not night killable and got robbed once.

One of the people who was not night killable was doc_bean (Italian Godfather).

The other, whom I tried to kill this last round, was Sigurd Fafnesbane.

He is probably the chinese godfather. He knows I'm not Italian mafia and not Chinese, but finds it convenient to throw together some 'clues' that I'm guilty and throw the trail off the real chinese mafia.

So go ahead, kill me. But kill Sigurd, leader of the triads, next round.

Crazed Rabbit

[Kommodus]

I'm the serial killer. The last three times I killed noone because I attacked two people who were not night killable and got robbed once.

No kidding... if what you say is true, then you're my killer! Looks like you got me back for Mafia III, huh? Or wait... you actually killed me in this game before I killed you in the other... so maybe I got you back. Or whatever; either way it looks like we were brutally murdering each other at almost exactly the same time. Oh, it's dripping with irony.

Maybe you and I should bury the hatchet, eh bro? We're both reasonably intelligent people who aren't half bad at the game of Mafia. How 'bout it?

[Crazed Rabbit]

Sounds good to me Kommodus. In fact, I did kill you in this game before you got me in Mafia III. I think I went for you before I really suspected your guilt in Mafia III, because of your spreadsheet.
(I also killed Disco, as I had forgotten he was first to die in Mafia III, sorry)

I'm kind of sad. I was planning to do this story about some psychotic guy who thought he was serving some kind of high purpose. But mafia dons and robbers have kept me thwarted. And as of late I've been more suspected in games.

*note to Sasaki; if it is at all possible, I want to commit suicide with a hammer. Or hanging from a gnarled tree. If not, I'll take the lynching like a man, yelling at the petty, small minded people of this town and that I will take my vengence*

Also, a note to villagers; remember what I said about Sigurd and Doc_bean. EDIT: Also, when I said you wouldn't lynch a mafia goon by killing me, I wasn't lying.

Crazed Rabbit

[Kommodus]

I was planning to do this story about some psychotic guy who thought he was serving some kind of high purpose.

What'd'ya know... looks like you and I have more in common after all! I'm sure you noticed a similar theme in my stories from Mafia III. Although, if my death here was any indication, it looked like your character had some kind of spiritual purpose in mind, while mine was a naturalistic villain. Ironic once again, since in reality I'm a man of faith.

It is a bit sad, actually, since you only get one chance at writing the story you want. Once you're dead, you really can't try it again in any future game - at least not for a long time. Guess you know the feeling now. I wish you'd have made it further.

[GeneralHankerchief]

What'd'ya know... looks like you and I have more in common after all! I'm sure you noticed a similar theme in my stories from Mafia III. Although, if my death here was any indication, it looked like your character had some kind of spiritual purpose in mind, while mine was a naturalistic villain. Ironic once again, since in reality I'm a man of faith.

It is a bit sad, actually, since you only get one chance at writing the story you want. Once you're dead, you really can't try it again in any future game - at least not for a long time. Guess you know the feeling now. I wish you'd have made it further.

At least yours had an ending.

Out of curiosity, how would it have ended had you got your way (to both of you)?

[Kommodus]

Out of curiosity, how would it have ended had you got your way (to both of you)?

Mine would've ended like this:

Self-replicating nanites, which build themselves from biological material, quickly spread throughout the globe. They don't target humans indiscriminately, but instead can be programmed to target them based on a wide variety of arbitrary factors. These factors can include genetic and other biological characteristics, geographical location, etc.

The actual goal of the nanite plague is to eliminate social ills such as genetic defects, disease, poverty, overpopulation, human-caused environmental catastrophies, and persistent conflicts. Thus, the nanites' first targets include the sick, disabled, elderly, and others who are deemed a "burden" to society. They also eliminate anyone with a genetic makeup judged to be "inferior." They then move on to areas where economic health is poor, wiping out entire famine and poverty-striken regions. Finally, they target areas of unending conflict, ending wars by wiping out all sides.

These massive cullings end up wiping out most of the planet's population and causing the collapse of civilization as we know it. Industry and technology are set back by hundreds of years. Only a small percentage of humanity remains. Those few survivors are supposedly the brightest, strongest, and healthiest people, and are left to try to rebuild society as best they can. The Mafia seize power in the aftermath, attempting to guide the development of civilization as they see fit.

Why would I pick a doomsday scenario such as this? Well, I felt like creating a story in which one man's philosophy of Social Darwinism goes horribly wrong. The whole idea of eugenics - the idea that man can "play god" by artificially selecting which humans should live and which should die - has been proposed many times throughout history in many different forms. Often it's led to unimaginable extremes of evil. Therefore it's among my most hated philosophies, so I gave it to the villain in my story.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

Crazed Rabbit has been executed

Killed(7):
Discovery1 (Bus Driver)
Silver Rusher (Italian Mafioso + Romeo)
gertgregoor (cop)
Kommodus (mason)
GeneralHankerchief(cop)
SSNeoperestroika(mayor)
Ice(Italian Mafioso)

Suicide(1):
Drisos (Juliet)

Left Town(1):
Divinus Arma (Jerry)

Executed(5):
Orb (Chinese Mafia)
Zalmoxis (doctor)
Lemur (Tom)
doc_bean(Italian Godfather)
Crazed Rabbit (Serial Killer)

Alive (9):
Reenk Roink
Cowhead418
Tiberius
evil_maniac_from_mars
Wonderland
Ignoramus
B_Ray
Sigurd Fafnesbane
Dutch_Guy

PM's please

[Avicenna]

Vote: Sigurd Fafnesbane

CR has some good use of logic up there.

[Sigurd]

A little trigger happy there Tib?

Anyways, now that the mafia know that I am hard to kill, and yes there are other roles beside godfathers that can’t be killed by servants of the night,
I am a little troubled that I might not be able to use my special ability.

I hoped I could survive long enough to find out who the last mafia was in the final rounds of this game without getting lynched and go out with a boom and ensure town victory. The Mafia will of course now be desperate to lynch me since they realise who I am.
Look back into this thread and you’ll realise why there were so few kills in some rounds.
I suspect there are a few more of us that can’t be killed by mafia.

I have been waiting for the one to name me as a lynch candidate for a while now, knowing that he could possibly be a mafia and almost certainly be a night killer.
Now that CR called me a Godfather it is understandable that some will believe this and call me on it.
My trap has sprung with no one in it.

[Avicenna]

What's this.. a thieving prostitute?

EDIT: wait, a prosititute would report a break in wouldn't it?

[Sasaki Kojiro]

Ignoramus has been killed.

Sigurd Fafnesbane reports that his house has been broken into.

Killed(8):
Discovery1 (Bus Driver)
Silver Rusher (Italian Mafioso + Romeo)
gertgregoor (cop)
Kommodus (mason)
GeneralHankerchief(cop)
SSNeoperestroika(mayor)
Ice(Italian Mafioso)
Ignoramus(prostitute)

Suicide(1):
Drisos (Juliet)

Left Town(1):
Divinus Arma (Jerry)

Executed(5):
Orb (Chinese Mafia)
Zalmoxis (doctor)
Lemur (Tom)
doc_bean(Italian Godfather)
Crazed Rabbit (Serial Killer)

Alive (8):
Reenk Roink
Cowhead418
Tiberius
evil_maniac_from_mars
Wonderland
B_Ray
Sigurd Fafnesbane
Dutch_Guy

[Sasaki Kojiro]

Uff. People need to vote this game has started before silver rushers and yet we still have 8 left. Next time I think I'll impose more deadlines.

48 hours to vote or I kill you.

[Dutch_guy]

Vote:Wonderland

With such a, well, uneventfull kill we don't have a lot to go on.

[Silver Rusher]

Uff. People need to vote this game has started before silver rushers and yet we still have 8 left. Next time I think I'll impose more deadlines.

48 hours to vote or I kill you.

I agree. Now that we are in full swing of our mafia obsession, the only way to stop a game from dying really is to impose strict rules on inactivity and have set vote deadlines.

[Orb]

yep, right sort of idea.

[Reenk Roink]

Vote: Sigurd F.

He was listed, and got visited by our behind the scenes hero but wasn't in the house presumably.

[Sigurd]

Alright RR,

Let’s go through this step by step…
We know that mafia members can be killed during the night (Silver Rusher)
The way I understand it a Godfather orders his Mafiosi whom to kill during the night and does not leave his own house during the night.
The Chinese mafia has a Godfather and a Mafioso left in this game. The only two threats left.
I can be neither as proven by combining the evidences from CR and our nightly robber.

We have to slow down and not let Sasaki’s 48 hour time limit scare us into doing something foolish. Time has so far been our friend and our lynching streak is impressive. Let’s get the rest of the mafia.
The mafia must be sitting on needles with only 8 of us left. 6 against 2. If we lynch one of our own it will be 4 against two after next night. If we lynch another one of us, the mafia wins.
The next two lynches is critical.
We still do not have much to work with. Tiberius was quite fast to name me after CR’s execution. He could be the remaining Mafioso. Both doc-bean and B-Ray revealed insight in the Tom & Jerry situation, both naming Lemur as Tom. Only the mafia knew about Lemur’s true identity when he was imprisoned. Since doc_bean has been revealed as the Italian Godfather my suspicions go to B-Ray as our Chinese Godfather since both had intimate knowledge of Lemur’s true identity. It is probably the Godfather that sends the night’s killings to Sasaki and Tiberius sitting on needles didn’t quite catch that the killings had not been posted yet. He took the opportunity to go after the obvious.
From these observations I am bold enough to call Tiberius on this little mistake.

Vote: Tiberius.

Ps: A little adivce to the thief; maybe make a visit to B-Ray's house now that he will have to do his killing himself.

Pps: The Mafia will be all over me now trying to get me killed...

[Evil_Maniac From Mars]

Vote: Sigurd Fafnesbane

I'm absoloutly sure of it.

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

And I'm also sure I can't spell that word.

[Crazed Rabbit]

As the people of this once peaceful town pass by CR's old house, they notice a peculiar statue in front. It is a life size statue of the dearly departed CR, glaring in an admonishing manner at passer-by as if to remind them of something.

CR

[Reenk Roink]

Alright RR,

Let’s go through this step by step…
We know that mafia members can be killed during the night (Silver Rusher)
The way I understand it a Godfather orders his Mafiosi whom to kill during the night and does not leave his own house during the night.
The Chinese mafia has a Godfather and a Mafioso left in this game. The only two threats left.
I can be neither as proven by combining the evidences from CR and our nightly robber.

We have to slow down and not let Sasaki’s 48 hour time limit scare us into doing something foolish. Time has so far been our friend and our lynching streak is impressive. Let’s get the rest of the mafia.
The mafia must be sitting on needles with only 8 of us left. 6 against 2. If we lynch one of our own it will be 4 against two after next night. If we lynch another one of us, the mafia wins.
The next two lynches is critical.
We still do not have much to work with. Tiberius was quite fast to name me after CR’s execution. He could be the remaining Mafioso. Both doc-bean and B-Ray revealed insight in the Tom & Jerry situation, both naming Lemur as Tom. Only the mafia knew about Lemur’s true identity when he was imprisoned. Since doc_bean has been revealed as the Italian Godfather my suspicions go to B-Ray as our Chinese Godfather since both had intimate knowledge of Lemur’s true identity. It is probably the Godfather that sends the night’s killings to Sasaki and Tiberius sitting on needles didn’t quite catch that the killings had not been posted yet. He took the opportunity to go after the obvious.
From these observations I am bold enough to call Tiberius on this little mistake.

Vote: Tiberius.

Ps: A little adivce to the thief; maybe make a visit to B-Ray's house now that he will have to do his killing himself.

Pps: The Mafia will be all over me now trying to get me killed...

Wow, you're right Sig, sorry 'bout that...

Unvote: Sig
Vote: Tiberius

[Cowhead418]

Alright RR,

Let’s go through this step by step…
We know that mafia members can be killed during the night (Silver Rusher)
The way I understand it a Godfather orders his Mafiosi whom to kill during the night and does not leave his own house during the night.
The Chinese mafia has a Godfather and a Mafioso left in this game. The only two threats left.
I can be neither as proven by combining the evidences from CR and our nightly robber.

We have to slow down and not let Sasaki’s 48 hour time limit scare us into doing something foolish. Time has so far been our friend and our lynching streak is impressive. Let’s get the rest of the mafia.
The mafia must be sitting on needles with only 8 of us left. 6 against 2. If we lynch one of our own it will be 4 against two after next night. If we lynch another one of us, the mafia wins.
The next two lynches is critical.
We still do not have much to work with. Tiberius was quite fast to name me after CR’s execution. He could be the remaining Mafioso. Both doc-bean and B-Ray revealed insight in the Tom & Jerry situation, both naming Lemur as Tom. Only the mafia knew about Lemur’s true identity when he was imprisoned. Since doc_bean has been revealed as the Italian Godfather my suspicions go to B-Ray as our Chinese Godfather since both had intimate knowledge of Lemur’s true identity. It is probably the Godfather that sends the night’s killings to Sasaki and Tiberius sitting on needles didn’t quite catch that the killings had not been posted yet. He took the opportunity to go after the obvious.
From these observations I am bold enough to call Tiberius on this little mistake.

Vote: Tiberius.

Ps: A little adivce to the thief; maybe make a visit to B-Ray's house now that he will have to do his killing himself.

Pps: The Mafia will be all over me now trying to get me killed...

Great, great analysis. As someone who has been in the mafia twice now I can tell you that a method that has worked well is voting right after the next kills in hopes of starting a bandwagon on an innocent. It worked quite well in SR's game because we had such a bloodthirsty mob. Tiberius is certainly suspicious due to the fact that he voted before the next kills were even posted. Vote: Tiberius

[Sasaki Kojiro]

Tiberius has been lynched.

Also, B_Ray has left town (he's in australia actually, hasn't visited in 9 days).

Killed(8):
Discovery1 (Bus Driver)
Silver Rusher (Italian Mafioso + Romeo)
gertgregoor (cop)
Kommodus (mason)
GeneralHankerchief(cop)
SSNeoperestroika(mayor)
Ice(Italian Mafioso)
Ignoramus(prostitute)

Suicide(1):
Drisos (Juliet)

Left Town(2):
Divinus Arma (Jerry)
B_Ray (Mason)


Executed(6):
Orb (Chinese Mafia)
Zalmoxis (doctor)
Lemur (Tom)
doc_bean(Italian Godfather)
Crazed Rabbit (Serial Killer)
Tiberius (Mason)

Alive (6):
Reenk Roink
Cowhead418
evil_maniac_from_mars
Wonderland
Sigurd Fafnesbane
Dutch_Guy

Pm's please.