Quote Originally Posted by GeneralHankerchief
You convinced me, Doc.

There were three murder attempts the first night. Tib got lucky because he was saved. This time there were only two attempts. Which means that somebody had to get held up. Now, the thief blocks a certain person's action that night. Simple math, don't know why I didn't see it before.

Unvote: B_Ray

Vote: Orb
So do we know that the thief targeted Orb because his newspapers were stolen? I'd assume so. Remember, however, that Silver Rusher was an Italian Mafioso, meaning that he probably conducted one of the attempts the first night. I will refrain from voting for now.