Mini-Mafia [Concluded]

**Sasaki Kojiro** · 09-07-2006, 22:25

In my experience in a game of this setup, the odds of lynching a mafioso first round are very low. However, on day 2 you have 2 confirmed innocents and a 2/5 chance of getting mafia, then the first days discussion becomes invaluable in figuring out who they are.

sidenote @ Silver Rusher: if psychoanalysis is always wrong, then you can confirm people as innocent by using it :p

but actually it can work, you just can't see it in the games we've had because we're all new at it.

Vote Count

Drisos 1 (Silver Rusher)
Silver Rusher 1 (General Hankerchief)

not voting (Kagemusha, Sigurd, Crazed Rabbit, Dutch_Guy, Drisos)

**Silver Rusher** · 09-07-2006, 22:30

Sasaki, sure you can use psychoanalysis and sure it may work once in a while but the Mafia are far more likely to outsmart you if you do that. That is one of the main parts of their job.

Another thing, why is it that merely voting makes me too eager/overeager for a lynching? Voting is something that you are supposed to do in Mafia.

**GeneralHankerchief** · 09-07-2006, 22:37

Originally Posted by Silver Rusher

Another thing, why is it that merely voting makes me too eager/overeager for a lynching? Voting is something that you are supposed to do in Mafia.

A) It was done early on when we had pretty much agreed to talk before voting.

B) Your reason was extremely suspicious.

C) Now that you are under fire for it you are attacking psychoanalysis far more than necessary.

My vote stands.

**Drisos** · 09-08-2006, 13:19

If we vote in a circle, no one gets lynched.. which is better anyway when we don't have any clues to the mafia identity.

therefor, I vote GHC

all three of us 1 vote.. if the other three voters vote all on the same one of us, he dies. but I doubt that.

let's see who gets killed first round

**Kagemusha** · 09-08-2006, 15:11

I have been thinking and thinking,but there is no evidence against anybody so all i can do is to follow my instinct.Becouse i have to vote someone i Vote Dutch Guy.The only reasoning i can come up with that is that becouse he didnt point out a mafia member like in the last games with his post,i think he is Mafia himself.

**Dutch_guy** · 09-08-2006, 15:44

Originally Posted by Kagemusha

I have been thinking and thinking,but there is no evidence against anybody so all i can do is to follow my instinct.Becouse i have to vote someone i Vote Dutch Guy.The only reasoning i can come up with that is that becouse he didnt point out a mafia member like in the last games with his post,i think he is Mafia himself.

I have absolutely nothing to go on, and you know it. In the other games it was always something at least...

**Kagemusha** · 09-08-2006, 16:04

Originally Posted by Dutch_guy

I have absolutely nothing to go on, and you know it. In the other games it was always something at least...

I have exactly the same problem.Anyway we are going to kill an innocent person becouse there is no murder yet there are only couple Mafiosos planning a murder. This whole first round is just shooting at the Dark.One way would be like Drisos suggested vote in a circle so everybody gets a one vote so no one gets executed.