Mafia IV: Night of the Living Mafia [Concluded]

**Csargo** · 10-09-2006, 03:31

Don't lie Sasaki you killed me why don't you admit it. I know it was you.

SR does this mean I get to join the MVFJA

Ice your a mafioso too don't lie.

**Sasaki Kojiro** · 10-09-2006, 03:33

Originally Posted by Csar

Don't lie Sasaki you killed me why don't you admit it. I know it was you.

SR does this mean I get to join the

No way Csar I wouldn't have killed you. I'd keep the active posters alive so that in the endgame people weren't like "why is Sasaki the only active poster alive".

**Csargo** · 10-09-2006, 03:49

Oh and something else I think may be useful is that me and Leet are active chat users.

**Csargo** · 10-09-2006, 04:17

Well at least now you all know I was innocent.

**Kommodus** · 10-09-2006, 04:31

Wow, the townspeople are really working hard to be as clever as possible in this game. I feel sorry for the Mafia.

Silver and Myrdraal, that's a clever trap you set for 'ol Sasaki. You definitely get an "A" for effort - I've never seen someone work so hard to find the mafia, in just about every game. However, if I properly understand the sequence of PM's that went back and forth, I have to say I think you're making a mistake. Killing Myrdraal would not be a logical course for Sasaki, were he truly guilty.

No, my friends, the guilty party here is Masy. How do I know, you ask? You probably won't like my answer. You may remember how, at the end of Mafia III, I said that if I had really been a villager, I'd have looked for a new method of analysis, rather than using my tired, old, and easily-defeated spreadsheet from Mafia II.

Well, that's what I've been working on, and it's yielded results, with greater speed and reliability than my older methods. Unfortunately, as in Mafia II, I can't reveal it at this time. Why, you ask? Once again, because knowledge of it would help the mafia defeat it.

However, I am very confident of this: Masy is in the mafia. Do the town a favor and take 'im down.

Masy, oh Masy the Mafioso, please do not take this personally. Having been a mobster previously, I know it can be a difficult burden to bear, and I have respect for all who must wear the mantle. I hope you've enjoyed your time in the Cosa Nostra, and a part of me wishes it'd lasted longer, as I know you do. You had a tremendous challenge before you.

Vote: Masy

**discovery1** · 10-09-2006, 04:49

Originally Posted by Kommodus

Wow, the townspeople are really working hard to be as clever as possible in this game. I feel sorry for the Mafia.

Silver and Myrdraal, that's a clever trap you set for 'ol Sasaki. You definitely get an "A" for effort - I've never seen someone work so hard to find the mafia, in just about every game. However, if I properly understand the sequence of PM's that went back and forth, I have to say I think you're making a mistake. Killing Myrdraal would not be a logical course for Sasaki, were he truly guilty.

No, my friends, the guilty party here is Masy. How do I know, you ask? You probably won't like my answer. You may remember how, at the end of Mafia III, I said that if I had really been a villager, I'd have looked for a new method of analysis, rather than using my tired, old, and easily-defeated spreadsheet from Mafia II.

Well, that's what I've been working on, and it's yielded results, with greater speed and reliability than my older methods. Unfortunately, as in Mafia II, I can't reveal it at this time. Why, you ask? Once again, because knowledge of it would help the mafia defeat it.

However, I am very confident of this: Masy is in the mafia. Do the town a favor and take 'im down.

Masy, oh Masy the Mafioso, please do not take this personally. Having been a mobster previously, I know it can be a difficult burden to bear, and I have respect for all who must wear the mantle. I hope you've enjoyed your time in the Cosa Nostra, and a part of me wishes it'd lasted longer, as I know you do. You had a tremendous challenge before you.

Vote: Masy

Way to be totally sketch. YOu make me wish I set you as my target rather then Ice. You both side with him AND put forward the weakest of arguements.

**Crazed Rabbit** · 10-09-2006, 04:54

Vote: Sasaki
Same reasons as;

To me, Myrd getting offed seems just to much of a coincidence to be dismissed.

Sasaki, if he believed Myrd was going to PM others, might have killed him, as he would've thought Myrd would've defended him, thinking him innocent.

Also, on Silver's record in Mafia III... you'll note he changed his tone on Wonderland after he got my PM (I was detective that round, though did not state it in the PM).

CR

**discovery1** · 10-09-2006, 05:32

And might I add that you sided with Ice for no real reason, since I vote for him because he goes to U of M at Ann Arbor.

**Kommodus** · 10-09-2006, 13:21

Originally Posted by discovery1

Way to be totally sketch. YOu make me wish I set you as my target rather then Ice. You both side with him AND put forward the weakest of arguements.

Come now, discovery1, I had no intention of participating in this "feud" you and Ice seem to have. I voted for you based on a shred of evidence which seemed to be the only thing I had at the time. I do apologize for this, since I now know you were innocent.

As for the rest of you, you can trust me, or not. I participate in these games partly out of intellectual curiosity: can I solve the puzzle before it's too late? In this case I'm already satisfied; my method doesn't require me to be alive in order to work.

I'm still not going to tell you how I did it. Does this disappoint you or make you suspicious? Very well then; so be it. Do what you will; the truth will be out soon enough.

**Dutch_guy** · 10-09-2006, 13:27

So, Masy is a mafioso according to your mysterious evidence, and who else ?

As you said, you can continue your work in death - so why not just save us villagers while you still can ?

**Csargo** · 10-09-2006, 05:58

Originally Posted by Kommodus

Wow, the townspeople are really working hard to be as clever as possible in this game. I feel sorry for the Mafia.

Silver and Myrdraal, that's a clever trap you set for 'ol Sasaki. You definitely get an "A" for effort - I've never seen someone work so hard to find the mafia, in just about every game. However, if I properly understand the sequence of PM's that went back and forth, I have to say I think you're making a mistake. Killing Myrdraal would not be a logical course for Sasaki, were he truly guilty.

No, my friends, the guilty party here is Masy. How do I know, you ask? You probably won't like my answer. You may remember how, at the end of Mafia III, I said that if I had really been a villager, I'd have looked for a new method of analysis, rather than using my tired, old, and easily-defeated spreadsheet from Mafia II.

Well, that's what I've been working on, and it's yielded results, with greater speed and reliability than my older methods. Unfortunately, as in Mafia II, I can't reveal it at this time. Why, you ask? Once again, because knowledge of it would help the mafia defeat it.

However, I am very confident of this: Masy is in the mafia. Do the town a favor and take 'im down.

Masy, oh Masy the Mafioso, please do not take this personally. Having been a mobster previously, I know it can be a difficult burden to bear, and I have respect for all who must wear the mantle. I hope you've enjoyed your time in the Cosa Nostra, and a part of me wishes it'd lasted longer, as I know you do. You had a tremendous challenge before you.

Vote: Masy

I don't see how you could get anything out of two rounds of voting. Like Disco said you voted for him for no reason. But so did I so I'll forgive you for that one. But still how do the villagers know you can trust them?

**Drisos** · 10-09-2006, 06:18

Vote: Masy

Due to the 'wrong' posting times at the first round, and suspicious posting.

However I'm still highly suspicious of Sasaki. And now Kommodus as well.

Long post - but not that much said//

**doc_bean** · 10-09-2006, 08:27

Vote: Kommodus

Certainty after two rounds of voting ? Highly unlikely.
Participating in the Ice/Disco feud ? Highly Suspicious.
Pretending to be the helpful villager ? Errr...dangerous, but if it works it really pays off.

As for Sasaki, I'm still suspicious, but I'm with BKS and Sasaki thinking it just wouldn't make sense. Besides, Sasaki likes playing with people, he would have went along a bit longer I suspect.