Quote Originally Posted by doc_bean
I'm always eager for a kill, you should know that by now

But onto your argument: who's to say the mafia hasn't already gotten one of the good guys ? Who's the say the odds haven't turned in our favour already ? And what about next round, two more people will be dead, will it be in our interest to lunch people then ? Yes/No ? The odds would probably still be against the good guys. Now we have a chance of killing a mafia member, tonight's victims will surely be innocents...

Besides, active debate sometimes makes the mafia make mistakes (like not participating, or saying too much, it's win-win for the townies) AND it allows the detectives to be subtle, with few people posting/voting, those that do and point out the right people will immediately become targets.
I'm all for active debate, I made that clear. After 3 rounds of kills from mafia they would most likely have killed a pro-town role (31 players 3 mafia, so 4/28 or 1/7 chance each kill) and then we could go lynch. Since BKS was a doctor it is now in our advantage to lynch.