The Godfather, Part 2 [Concluded]

[Silver Rusher]

Silver's choice to end it this round implies, but does NOT confirm, that Divine Wind is the Chief of Police and nothing more, since one more round would be, techically, possible were he the GF. It's possible that this is just a gamesmaster's choice to promote playability.

If you are basing it on the idea that if DW is the Godfather he can be left a round as he cannot vote, I am allowing him to vote in this round. Basically, nobody is a technical exception to the possibility of being the Godfather.

[Csargo]

Vote: Husar

You make no sense at all too me man. Your crazy.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

You thought Sigurd was guilty though, didn't you Csar? Voting for someone you don't suspect makes no sense...for a townie.

[Csargo]

You thought Sigurd was guilty though, didn't you Csar? Voting for someone you don't suspect makes no sense...for a townie.

I had a choice between Sigurd, DW, and Husar. I chose Husar cause he voted me for no apparent reason so I retaliated by voting for him. Everyone is suspicious right now.

[Myrddraal]

Was the only person to believe that ridiculous PM I posted to take the heat off of my fellow Detective Myrddraal.

I don't know what to believe any more. GH has been talking to me in private, assuring me his fake PM was meant to save me...

[Seamus Fermanagh]

If you are basing it on the idea that if DW is the Godfather he can be left a round as he cannot vote, I am allowing him to vote in this round. Basically, nobody is a technical exception to the possibility of being the Godfather.

Under your rules, it was at least technically possible. I had thought you made the decision to end it this round largely for gameplay reasons -- no offense was intended, as I thought it a good decision to help close out a nicely run game.

Players, please note that this means 4 active votes.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

I had a choice between Sigurd, DW, and Husar. I chose Husar cause he voted me for no apparent reason so I retaliated by voting for him. Everyone is suspicious right now.

I voted Sigurd because I think he is the Godfather or DW which seems more likely to be it now that I think about it.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

I don't know what to believe any more. GH has been talking to me in private, assuring me his fake PM was meant to save me...

You'd have done better to go with that story all along


edit: I think it will be most advantageous to the town to examine Csar, Husar, Sigurd, and DW closely, rather than spend time on Sasaky/Myrd/GH/Seamus.

[Seamus Fermanagh]

I had a choice between Sigurd, DW, and Husar. I chose Husar cause he voted me for no apparent reason so I retaliated by voting for him. Everyone is suspicious right now.

Actually, his vote was pretty clearly motivated. Absent Masy the "lurker" your sparse posting and voting record that more strongly supported GH/Myrd than any remaining player, made you an easy suspect -- provided that you disbelieve the detective status of GH/Myrd.

The fact that everyone is still somewhat suspicious leads me to expect a bloodbath finish.

[Sasaki Kojiro]

Well, either:

1) DW was godfather and the game was over because he had no way to win

or

2) DW was innocent and Silver didn't want us to be able to eliminate him from a possible lynch candidate this round.

If you are basing it on the idea that if DW is the Godfather he can be left a round as he cannot vote, I am allowing him to vote in this round. Basically, nobody is a technical exception to the possibility of being the Godfather.

The phrasing of this sentance leads me to believe option 2 is correct..."nobody is a technical exception" sounds a lot like "I don't want you to be able to eliminate him as a possible candidate".

[Sasaki Kojiro]

Actually, his vote was pretty clearly motivated. Absent Masy the "lurker" your sparse posting and voting record that more strongly supported GH/Myrd than any remaining player, made you an easy suspect -- provided that you disbelieve the detective status of GH/Myrd.

The fact that everyone is still somewhat suspicious leads me to expect a bloodbath finish.

Also, Husar confided to me via pm last round that he found Csar suspicious but was going to say he found him innocent to improve his odds of surviving the night. Also, it means the kill provides more information:

• Masy though Csar was guilty
• Husar said he thought Csar was innocent

Masy got killed.

Now, Divine Wind would probably have killed Husar, wanting to eliminate someone who thought he was guilty and who thought Csar was innocent.

Sigurd would probably have gone for Husar as well since Masy could be counted on to vote for Csar.


Now, the mafia if they are smart have considered what it would look like if they chose to kill a certain person. If I were mafia though, I would pay more attention to who found who suspicious, reasoning that I could always argue my way out of this kind of accusation.

[Husar]

Sasaki just explained my reasoning, I actually thought that the way I said that I found Csar innocent was really bad and noone would believe it, but apparently it worked. Also keep in mind that Sigurd is away this weekend which basically means he won't be here to vote, neither to write a PM with his kills.
My idea was to make Csar and Masy look innocent to get either of them killed, I know I am a cruel townie because of that, but Sasaki explained the reasoning that follows out of Masy's death now.
Since there is apparently only DW left to vote now I hope he can understand this reasoning.
Obviously Csar was surprised that I voted for him and didn't even ask why I had this change in my behaviour. I am inclined to believe that he really believed that I found him to be innocent, thus he killed Masy and then he just said I had no reason to vote for him, wouldn't a more natural reason be to ask why I suddenly changed my opinion?

[Divine Wind]

Oki Dokie,

Firstly, I apologise for not being active at all in this game for a while. My PC went kaput about a week ago, so I was only able to check up on the game at work. I wanted to contribute but I was far to busy, plus my boss sits right behind me so it was a little risky reading through the forum with his lurking eyes behind me.

I have no idea who is guilty, as the pace of this game has been to quick for me to read through (new computer + MTW2 = no time). Anyway, as I can actually vote for this last round ill make my vote at the toss of a coin between Husar, and Csar.

Vote: Csar

To put your minds at ease, I am innocent, as you will all find out tommorow.

[Csargo]

Sasaki just explained my reasoning, I actually thought that the way I said that I found Csar innocent was really bad and noone would believe it, but apparently it worked. Also keep in mind that Sigurd is away this weekend which basically means he won't be here to vote, neither to write a PM with his kills.
My idea was to make Csar and Masy look innocent to get either of them killed, I know I am a cruel townie because of that, but Sasaki explained the reasoning that follows out of Masy's death now.
Since there is apparently only DW left to vote now I hope he can understand this reasoning.
Obviously Csar was surprised that I voted for him and didn't even ask why I had this change in my behaviour. I am inclined to believe that he really believed that I found him to be innocent, thus he killed Masy and then he just said I had no reason to vote for him, wouldn't a more natural reason be to ask why I suddenly changed my opinion?

What do you think I am a dumb-ass? For my so called teaming up with Myrd and GH who would not think I am suspicious or guilty? That's about as bad as Ignoramus's PM to Sigurd.

You would have done the same crap if I would have voted Sigurd or DW. You know it and I know it I just hope everyone else realizes that too. You've done it the entire game to Myrd, GH, and everyone else you've accused through out the game.

I'll be laughing in all your faces when you lose this game.

[GeneralHankerchief]

I'd just like to congratulate the Town on a great game. I'm fairly certain that we got the last mafioso.

Why? Because at last you remembered our investigations. Out of the three votes cast so far, none of them have been for the two people that Myrd and I confirmed as innocent (Sigurd and DW). This leaves Csar and Husar. Out of the two, Csar has acted the more suspicious, saying that us two Detectives were "full of crap," whilst Husar actually lobbied to keep the voting longer while I got lynched.

Sigurd, if you get on, vote Csar. Finish it off. Save the Gameroom. End the game.

[Husar]

What do you think I am a dumb-ass?

I didn't say that...

For my so called teaming up with Myrd and GH who would not think I am suspicious or guilty? That's about as bad as Ignoramus's PM to Sigurd.

You would have done the same crap if I would have voted Sigurd or DW. You know it and I know it I just hope everyone else realizes that too. You've done it the entire game to Myrd, GH, and everyone else you've accused through out the game.

I'll be laughing in all your faces when you lose this game.

Why so angry and aggressive all of a sudden?

[GeneralHankerchief]

Because he's about to lose, and his mafioso buddies are silent. The game is at stake here, of course he'd be aggressive.

[GeneralHankerchief]

If you are basing it on the idea that if DW is the Godfather he can be left a round as he cannot vote, I am allowing him to vote in this round. Basically, nobody is a technical exception to the possibility of being the Godfather.

Aw... you never let me vote in the last round of GF1.

[Csargo]

I didn't say that...


Why so angry and aggressive all of a sudden?

What did I miss something where I can't defend myself properly? I'm not angry I'm pointing out the stupidity in your posts.

[Husar]

What did I miss something where I can't defend myself properly? I'm not angry I'm pointing out the stupidity in your posts.

Oh thanks, in that case maybe I should change my vote, but I'm afraid I am too stupid to do that...

[Csargo]

Oh thanks, in that case maybe I should change my vote, but I'm afraid I am too stupid to do that...

No offense ment I wasn't talking about you I was talking about your post but you pretty much implied that I was an idiot with your idiotic frame attempt on me which is obviously working for someone.

[Death Match]

tommorow you will find out who i was...

[Sigurd]

I guess it is up to me huh?

I need time to think this over... I will give my vote a little later today.

[Husar]

No offense ment I wasn't talking about you I was talking about your post but you pretty much implied that I was an idiot with your idiotic frame attempt on me which is obviously working for someone.

Normal people make mistakes, too, no need to feel like an idiot.

That "idiotiv frame attempt" of mine was also meant to give me some additional security to my already existing suspicion. It's not my only reason for voting.

[Sigurd]

I got a little bird telling me the voting is about to close and I can't say I have a clue to whom the godfather might be.

Csar has two votes and Husar has one.

DW and I have none.

If I was the Godfather I could have ended it right here and now with a big MUAHHAHHAHAHHAHHAHH..

GH is pressing for a vote on Csar... I know he has been lying on at least a couple of occations. I should not vote for Csar.

Myrddraal is wanting a vote for either DW or me.

If Myrddraal and GH both are mafia, they are diverting attention from Husar.
I can't change the fact that it will be either Csar or Husar going down this round.

If DW is the godfather the mafia wins.
I think I will buy us a little time by voting Husar. Will the narrator lynch them both? will there be a revote?

Vote: Husar

[Silver Rusher]

*****Voting Closed*****

[Silver Rusher]

Evening in the Gameroom.

This was supposed to be the end. Judgement day was supposed to have come already. But no, there had been a tie.

Husar and Csar had each got 2 votes, Husar's from Csar and Sigurd Fafnesbane and Csar's from Husar and Chief of Police Divine Wind.

The villagers collected at the graveyard by St. Alexandr's Chapel to be addressed by DW. "People, we have a tie. In such circumstances, there is only one way to handle this."

He looked up to the sky.

"Err... God?" he called in a feeble, quivering voice.

"Who disturbs my slumber?" Silver Rusher's face appeared in the sky. "Oh, yes, DW. Don't worry, I know what to do."

A bolt of lightning hit the graveyard, and zombies started to climb out of the graves. Csar began screaming.

"It's alright, don't worry." DW turned to the zombies once they had collected in front of him, "We need all of you to vote for Csar or Husar to be executed. I still haven't decided how to execute whoever is lynched. God help us."

"Nah, do it yourself." DW jumped, and SR chuckled to himself.

Status List

Zombies: (dead but can vote)
Lemur
UltraWar
Major Robert Dump
Byzantine Mercenary
Sir Moody
theRTWGuru
Dutch_guy
Xiahou
Cowhead418
Proletariat
Don Corleone
Masy
Drisos
Kommodus
Sasaki Kojiro
Ignoramus
Evil_Maniac From Mars
GeneralHankerchief
Seamus Fernanagh
Crazed Rabbit
Myrddraal
Destroyer of Hope
Big King Sanctaphrax
Peasant Phill

Still alive:
Csar
Sigurd Fafnesbane
Husar
Divine Wind

4 players remain. All dead players may now vote in this round as well as the living, but all votes must be cast for either Csar or Husar.

[GeneralHankerchief]

Vote: Csar

[Masy]

'd just like to congratulate the Town on a great game. I'm fairly certain that we got the last mafioso.

Why? Because at last you remembered our investigations. Out of the three votes cast so far, none of them have been for the two people that Myrd and I confirmed as innocent (Sigurd and DW). This leaves Csar and Husar. Out of the two, Csar has acted the more suspicious, saying that us two Detectives were "full of crap," whilst Husar actually lobbied to keep the voting longer while I got lynched.

Sigurd, if you get on, vote Csar. Finish it off. Save the Gameroom. End the game.

Thought you said the game was all fake? Now you want to play it like it isn't?


Hmm. Nevertheless, I am inclined to Vote: Csar.

Hope this doesn't come back to bite me in the behind.

[GeneralHankerchief]

Thought you said the game was all fake? Now you want to play it like it isn't?


Hmm. Nevertheless, I am inclined to Vote: Csar.

Hope this doesn't come back to bite me in the behind.

Of course the PM was fake. I just wanted to sway voting away from Myrddraal, the person who I was sure was innocent.