Quote Originally Posted by GeneralHankerchief
#1: This was an error on our part. As previously said, we were just used to investigating the same person.
I believe you're better at being detective than that.

#2: No idea about this. I think the eight-digit thing corresponds to the last five numbers representing the word "MAFIA." So I get lynched based on a phone number that Silver did for a little effect.
The last 5 numbers don't represent the word mafia though. The 2nd number is '2' which could only be D E or F. Not A. The 555 thing is only in America. I don't know what British telephone numbers look like but the wikipedia article made it sound like they all start with 0 or something but I don't see how that works. Regardless, Silver wouldn't have used an American number, even by accident. That means the PM has to be faked, simple as that.
#3: Not outing Myrddraal would have required a lot of time to change the PM around, time which I did not have. At that point I was convinced that the bandwagon would roll against me, and you would happily push it along. Getting a quick reveal in was Priority #1.
All you had to do was asterisk out his name. 5 seconds tops. You would have done this.

#4: That is a lie. We never investigated Ignoramus, and Sigurd was only found innocent after Ig was lynched.
Excuse me? You said you did:

Quote Originally Posted by GeneralHankerchief
Round 1: Dutch_guy (innocent)
Round 2: Divine Wind (CoP) (innocent)
Round 3: Ignoramus (innocent)
Round 4: Sasaki Kojiro (just executed) (guilty)
Round 5: Sigurd Fafnesbane (innocent)
Round 6: Proletariat (innocent)
Now you are contradicting yourself? Or did you forget who you claimed you investigated?

#5: It is mentioned in the first post of the thread.
Yes, but Silver always includes all the rules in his PM's, even specific rules that aren't mentioned on the front page.
#6: Oh wow, so you're suddenly the universal definer of what a twist is? I believe that it is up to Silver on what falls into the realm of a twist in his game.
Yeah, fine. I can't prove anything here, it just doesn't seem very twisty to me.
#7: See #3. At the time I thought I had two out of the three votes cast.
Then you could have voted and tied it up.



This game has taxed me to the limit, but I will do my best to limit the damage and still try to pull off a Town victory. But I hope that a game this nasty and cutthroat is never played again. As said before, there's a reason why I don't go in the Backroom. Mafia needs to be fun first. Not the exhausting psychological marathon that it has become.

Anyway, a premature congrats to Sasaki and his two mafia buddies on their victory. Well played gentlemen, well played.
Being a mafioso can be pretty taxing, yeah? but nastiness and throat cutting has no place, I agree.




More people need to give their opinion on this. I find it really odd that Myrddraal hasn't posted since he's been on today.