Quote Originally Posted by Myrddraal
I'd say that's actually the most convincing thing so far. The theories posted so far have been quite weak. Not that surprising really so early in the game.
How so? The detective messages the game host. People private message for many reasons. Mods can see who people are investigating, if you or I had been watching the pm list we'd have seen "Sigurd Fafnesbane--Replying private message Kommodus" and would likely have thought they were mafia in cahoots, thus backfiring on Kommodus. If suspicion fell on Sigurd for being seen private messaging he would say "I was replying to Kommodus" post the pm, and perhaps accuse Kommodus of setting him up as he did here.

Not in the slightest bit convincing. I can see how Sigurd would take it that way...though...one does have to wonder if this was a plot to get Kommodus out of the game. Lynching him is the only way to off him without confirming his innocence. Hmm. I'm not sure it would be worth the loss of a mafioso and dropping down to 1 kill.