The Godfather, Part 2 [Concluded]

[Myrddraal]

you may notice that i voted for Don C

Thats interesting. I say that because my initial reaction was - well that's an obvious frame, surely... but it depends. Isn't this Don's first game, and he's been displaying a lot of ignorance of the way the game works (even if some of it is put on).

So we're left with two (or three) possibilities:

1. Don C is mafia, he decided to get back at Sir Moody without realising that this would be picked up on.

2. The mafia tried to frame Don C by going for Sir Moody

(3. I'm barking up the wrong tree, however I don't like option 3, everything should be considered and added to the Grand Scales of Justice (tm) )

Unfortunately, I think 1 and 2 are equally likely... 1 seems very possible, but then again, what are the chances that a more experienced mafioso wouldn't tell him what he was doing? 2 also seems possible, but it seems like a clumsy frame... I figure that after all these mafia games, simple frames like that surely don't work anymore?


Also did anyone else notice this:

and a Cessna Skyhawk flew into view.

Reminds me of Osmium and as such should be thoroughly ignored.
http://images.google.co.uk/images?hl...e=UTF-8&tab=wi

@ Dutch Guy

Which would confirm him as an innocent then, wouldn't it.

Well hes dead now, so yes... I feel like I'm missing something.


Vote: Don C
Because he's highest on my suspicious list. There isn't one thing which makes me suspicious of him, its the sum total of all the little things.





EDIT:

This leaves us with:
Cowhead418 (Voted first time only)
Sasaki Kojiro (voted Drisos each time)
Crazed Rabbit (first time only)
Dutch_guy (second time only, as the others below him)
Seamus Fermanagh
GeneralHankerchief
Divine Wind
BKS
Don Corleone
Csar

Interesting thought Crazed. We could rule out all the round 2 only people though.

And that leaves us with:

Cowhead418
Sasaki Kojiro
Crazed Rabbit

CR suggests this theory, Sasaki then goes to say almost anyone but him can't be suspected because of this. That leaves an interesting situation. Is is possible that CR is onto something and Sasaki is being very clever (it would be like him ). Is it possible that CR and Sasaki are in it together? Seems unlikely... and then we're left with Cowhead. I'm not sure what to make of this, Sasaki and Cowhead seem to come of worse for this evidence, but not much (either due to a very good false defence by Sasaki, or by way of actually being innocent). You could go around and around...

[Dutch_guy]

Thats interesting. I say that because my initial reaction was - well that's an obvious frame, surely... but it depends. Isn't this Don's first game, and he's been displaying a lot of ignorance of the way the game works (even if some of it is put on).

So we're left with two (or three) possibilities:

1. Don C is mafia, he decided to get back at Sir Moody without realising that this would be picked up on.

2. The mafia tried to frame Don C by going for Sir Moody

(3. I'm barking up the wrong tree, however I don't like option 3, everything should be considered and added to the Grand Scales of Justice (tm) )

Unfortunately, I think 1 and 2 are equally likely... 1 seems very possible, but then again, what are the chances that a more experienced mafioso wouldn't tell him what he was doing? 2 also seems possible, but it seems like a clumsy frame... I figure that after all these mafia games, simple frames like that surely don't work anymore?


Also did anyone else notice this:


Reminds me of Osmium and as such should be thoroughly ignored.
http://images.google.co.uk/images?hl...e=UTF-8&tab=wi

@ Dutch Guy

Well hes dead now, so yes... I feel like I'm missing something.


Vote: Don C
Because he's highest on my suspicious list. There isn't one thing which makes me suspicious of him, its the sum total of all the little things.





EDIT:




And that leaves us with:

Cowhead418
Sasaki Kojiro
Crazed Rabbit

CR suggests this theory, Sasaki then goes to say almost anyone but him can't be suspected because of this. That leaves an interesting situation. Is is possible that CR is onto something and Sasaki is being very clever (it would be like him ). Is it possible that CR and Sasaki are in it together? Seems unlikely... and then we're left with Cowhead. I'm not sure what to make of this, Sasaki and Cowhead seem to come of worse for this evidence, but not much (either due to a very good false defence by Sasaki, or by way of actually being innocent). You could go around and around...

Sorry for the late reply, but I had to react to this post, the part which quoted me of course.

Well, you might remember the chaos that ensued when Silver posted the kills a few turns back, it appeared that MRD was killed, but that Byz.merc was also killed. Now I missed the initial confusing, and afterwards thought that the mafia had planned to kill Byz Merc, but had decided to go for MRD. Now, I then proceeded to conclude that Silver's slip up just confirmed Byz Mercs innocence. Sadly, however, Byz Merc had been killed by the mafia, which needless to say also confirmed him innocent, but not In the way I imagined.

All in all, I probably misread the entire thing - as it was pretty confusing.

That clear enough ?