7/10 for a TW game 12/10 by normal standards.

Only 7/10 for a TW game, because I haven't been completely swept away by the evolution from RTW as I was from MTW - RTW also the bugs everyone keeps mentioning are annoying, the 1 turn to 2 years annoyed me and although it is moddable (and I have) it means that the game is mis-paced, lastly I am annoyed that in order to get a campaign map I have to spend another £15 on a collectors eddition, when this should be standard.

Although it might not sound it but I am generally very happy with the game, and with a little more thought CA could have fixed most of this and made it a 9/10.