Pic from 2005:

Robert E. Lee: 76%

More recent pic:

Matthew Fox: 74%, Emilio Estevez: 71%, Laurence Olivier: 63%, Tony Danza: 62%, Josh Hartnett: 61%, Sting: 60%, Jean-Cluade Van Damm: 58%, John Mayer: 57%, Jackie Chan: 57% (WTF!?!), Freddie Prinze Jr.: 56%, Nicholas Cage: 56%, Michael Ballack: 56%, Ruud Van Nistelroy: 56%.