Sorry for the 3 in one, as I said in a previous post i am used to alot of tacking on to post with editing features.

Anyway this isnt evident of the usual results I get with wedge, (usually wedge is just a bit worse than a 4 deep line which is my standard formation)

I think the wedge may have done badly because the dimpling effect caused the formation to be attacked on 2 sides and gaul warband, while being cr*p has spears which im fairly sure give them a small anti cavalry bonus.

But gaul warband is the usual sort of enemy I face (I either attack them 1st as julii or attack them after taking greece and macedon as brutii)