Lots of interesting theories developed, but none compelling.

If we believe that Seamus is relating stories that include clues rather than just random descriptions (which I hope to be the case as it gives us something to chew over) then I am suspicious of Proletariat.

Redleg's identification of Kagemusha's error brings him to the top of my list too, and the Kralizec theory has some, but not many legs.

There is too little to go on for any certainty, and as I am known to be a soft touch for innocence, you won't be surprised to hear that I:

Vote: No lynch