Quote Originally Posted by ByzantineKnight
Oh yah, I had forgotten about that, I don't think I agree with CrazedRabbit about it being a "insufficent members" attempted kill...

If it was a Insufficent Member attempted kill then it would have been more like "She cried out and her attackers seeing that the townspeople were coming to her aid and they were not powerful enough to withstand the tide of newcomers; fled" or something like that (or Seamus might not even have mentioned the attack).

If it was a doctor/surgeon save it would have said the doctor managed to heal her wounds or the like.

It cannot be a self-save, thus I think, by elimination, that it must have been a Luca save. Which coincidentaly could have had that write-up.

Right, I said this last post but I think it's needs to be reiterated. It doesn't follow in the slightest that the kill writeup reveals mafia. That's against the spirit of the game and Seamus has put too much thought into it to mess it up. Proletariat was saved by her luca or by a doctor I would think. I haven't read the kill description that closely but someone earlier mentioned a townie group that wasn't big enough being responsible for the failure.