playing medmod for the first time

[Noir]

I've had a run on this for a few hours, and its really as good as i was expecting.

Muslim factions are very tough for catholics this time around and wars with them dragged considerably. Melees also seem to last longer.

I've had two of the best battle moments/experiences in my TW "life" so far playing the French/early/hard/domination.

In one of them the "enemy" (english) came at me with a bunch of (4 or 5) Fyrdmen, two Muntators and their 4 valour, 6 command Engish archer general.

I on the other hand had two FMAA, two and a half FSs, two crossbows a 50 destrier and a 4 destrier general.

I've engaged one of the mutators as theycame to skirmish just before the main melee was joined with my destriers and one FSs. By the time they lost, the battle line was locked with one of my FMAA and my remaining FSs. I've checked with maneuvers the second muntators that was touring trying to find a chance to flank and unload their javelins (while at the same time protecting their archer general that was staying in a safe distance firing) with my destriers and flanked with the remaining unit of FMAA... perfect! their fyrdmen were encircled and my troops started taking them out - meanwhile my headstrong nobles engaged the muntators - finally - on their own. Although there was still time to pull them out i thought that this is better than to see their numbers down by english arrows and javelins. My nobles were losing though (probably due to the extra valour from the English general) and so to keep the muntators occupied a little longer i've sent my (4 men) general in that melee. Again it worked, by the time only my general's men were remaining, the main infantry melee was almost over (there were no fyrdmen survivors ).

Just in time to pull the general off and engage their battered muntators and archer general with my FSs, FMAA and finally my destrier general...

The second one was on a battle vs the Almohads - it was the very end of the battle and they had two units of nubians relatively intact and the remnants of their general ie three men of BC These were fighting against my two units of FSs in half manpower, the remnants of my general ie three men of Destriers. I also had 15 crossbowmen that somehow chose to stay in the battle and not rout...

Just before one of my FS were about to (predictably) rout and the second started weavering, the crossbowmen made their way on the Almohad general's back - just after my FS routed their general lied dead by two volleys of bolts in the back and the long chase of the nubian spearmen on their way out of my province started...

Ah, the beauty of TW...

[Kavhan Isbul]

There are many things I like about the MedMod, and one of them is the importance of every battle, especially in the beginning, when you cannot afford to lose as armies as they are so hard to replace.

[Noir]

I like the homelands a lot - although i would make them even more limited than what they currently are(no almohads in castille aragon and leon, no spanish in Cordoba, Serbs in Serbia and Croatia only, Bulgars in Bulgaria only - no celts in Elnglish provinces other than Northumbria); i also like the "styles" of the rosters (french feel finally french - Italians the same etc); subtracting the hybrid units is probably a good thing for the single player game - the Ai is good at match ups so it helps a lot in the battlefield. The starting positions are heaven and they are historically accurate too (so glad to see Constantinople with all the religious buildings in place as it should be!! - Rome with a cathedral etc).

The new provinces are great.

I might get the GA file (region owner table) calibrated for the early campaign and see how the game copes with that.

One thing from XL that could serve well here are the increased farming outputs relative to trade; however the Ai seems to be doing relatively ok.

Perhaps a fair decrease in build times for the castle line of buildings (and possibly a minor one for the military buildings too but of a minor order) to create a more dynamic game and make up for pillaging.

[Kavhan Isbul]

I personally agree that Bulgaria, Serbia and the Pechenegs should not have the same homelands as the Hungarians, but I would deffinitely add Thrace, Macedonia, Serbia, Wallachia and Epirus as homelands to the Bulgarians - after all, we did control Wallachia immediately after the liberation from the Byzantines, and at one pint in the thirteenth century most of the Balkans. A good case can be made about Moldavia and Pannonia. But I agree, Tyrolia, Volhynia and Austria are ridiculous. What applies to the Bulgarians, applies also to the Serbians (add Croatia and take away Thrace). As for the Spanish, they did retake the Iberian so I believe their current homelands are quite reasonable. If castille and Leon are taken away from the Almohads and Almoravids, they will get no iron provinces, and they need the upgrade badly considering they get no new troop types in late and their units are obsolete throughout the entire game (their early units are useless against the bellatores and feudal men at arms, their high units are better but more suited for the early period, really, and Jihads are the only lifeline providing decent troops).
I also do not think that the Cumans should share the same homelands and troops for the most part with the Novgorodians and Russians. I think the Pechenegs should not get Germanic Mercenaries as bodyguards should they survive until the High Period, but Avar Nobles (a fictionary fantasy unit with this name, as the Avars were wiped out loooooong before the start of the game, let alone 1204, but perhaps if renamed would make some sense), and that they should be able to produce horse archers in early and Steppe Cavalry throughout the game (instead of the Hungarian and Balkan troops).
There are also a few glitches that need fixing - switching the Pechenegs to pagans (they were anything but Catholics, and it is funny when the Pope intervenes on their behalf against the Hungarians or Poles), the Serbs to Orthodox, and the Cumans cannot produce ships, which is a bug (and effectively renders them defenseless against the superior Byzantines). Every faction seems to be able to produce Teutonic Order troops in high, which I admit I have been taking advantage of (those order sergeants come in handy against the Horde), but which I should try to fix.
Finally, I like that even the simplest troops, with few exceptions, take a lot of buildings and upgrades to produce, and that ships cannot be produced everywhere and linked to cover the entire map. I feel that the Catholics get a huge advantage by being able to build barques everywhere, and the Crusading factions get a huge advatage when it comes to homelands, but the AI does not seem to ever take advantage of this (but the Sicilians usually ravage through North Africa getting huge quantities of the Muslim troop types they are allowed to build).