Mini-Mafia like Game [Concluded]

[Orb]

Indeed. The pm could have been written by Warluster. He's a bit sloppy with his spelling sometimes, but not that sloppy. So maybe you fabricated the pm yourself.

Unless you forward it to me, I don't believe this is the role pm you got from Warluster.

So my vote still stands. En plus, you said Stig was certainly guilty, yet the murder attempts keep taking place. Is there a secret role, working together with the assassin? Are you taking a kill for the team?

Which vote?



Yep, I'm finding this completely suspect. Stig dead, no miraculous stop or even decrease in attacks.

[Alexander the Pretty Good]

I certainly can understand your suspicions. I've also forwarded my role PM to Orb and Andres.

I don't know why the killings didn't stop, but Stig was marked "Guilty" in the PM from Warluster after investigating him.

I played my hand too soon, thinking there was just one mafia. I was wrong, and it looks like it will cost the town.

[Stig]

I don't know why the killings didn't stop

I do, maybe it has to do with:
Stig = not mafia

[Andres]

I received Alexanders pm. It seems ok to me.

So, who do we have left?

Byzantine Knight. You knew Alexander was the spy, yet you didn't follow him.

I don't believe you didn't know that in this game spy=detective.

On the other hand, I have a question: I always tought you can not fake when you forward a pm. Am I right or am I mistaken? If I'm mistaken, I'll vote Alexander, if not, ByzantineKnight will get my vote.

[Csargo]

I received Alexanders pm. It seems ok to me.

So, who do we have left?

Byzantine Knight. You knew Alexander was the spy, yet you didn't follow him.

I don't believe you didn't know that in this game spy=detective.

On the other hand, I have a question: I always tought you can not fake when you forward a pm. Am I right or am I mistaken? If I'm mistaken, I'll vote Alexander, if not, ByzantineKnight will get my vote.

Yes, you can edit forwarded PM's.

[Andres]

GAH!!

Who to vote now?

Alexander = claims to be the spy, but posts a wrong result: Stig = guilty, but the killings didn't stop. PM's even forwarded can be faked. The particular pm could have been written by Warlusters, but there seem to be too many mistakes.

Compare some of Warluster's posts in other threads:

Cool, thanks for the info Stepehn Asen, I will make sure to always chech up historical info now. I am PM'ing a few people to see if they want to play, anyway, back to the game peoples.

*sigh*
Well thats two players out, I think it may be time to finish up this interactive, who agrees?

its like the Roman Empire, and Rised, got ripped apart, rised again, then massacerd, but the Eastern Empire kept on going...and going...and going...and going... and then they were all killed as well, oh well.

To the "role pm":

Hi,

Your role is an spy, it is your job to investigate one person a night, like an Detective, but we may have write-ups, PM me who you want to investigate and the persn will come up either Innocent or guilty. You are the only spy.

I also checked some of the Interactives where he participates. His English seems much better than that role pm.

Byzantine: Alexander sent him his role pm earlier on, yet he didn't believe him. He assumed "spy" was not the detective role, but that I don't believe. Maybe BK didn't buy Alexanders' pm and thought, like I do, it was a fake.

So : Vote : AlexanderThePrettyGood

I've seen way too much fake role pm's in Capo de Tutti Capi. Imho, Alexander is capable to try it in this game.

[Warluster]

Day 4 Lynching Results

This time the mood was grave. People were digging graves, and the Gravel amn was installing new Grave(l) The trumpets went off again, but this time with much less enthusiasm. Not many had voted, but not many were left. The town was dieing down, with the loss of one more. Everyone stormed out of there houses, some with the loss of freidns on there heart. They once again came to the platform, which had been fixed. And Warluster stood on it again.
"I have some graver news people" said Warluster, everyone looked up, especially the Grave(l) man.
"We have discovered, that there are obviously more then one Silento, and we may have got one already" said Warluster gravely, the grave(l) man was disappointed, no pay rise? but the towns People whispered in excitement, they were nearly all caught! Warluster raised his hand and spoke,
"But today one Dies, you have voted, and have decided, Alexander The pretty Good Shall be lycnhed today, can he please come up to the stage?' said Warluster, Alexander the pretty good nodded, and walked up the stage. Facing the crowd,
"Ihave one last request" said ATPG, Warluster nodded,
"I ahve here a list of suspicions, and have followed them for some time, one I know-" he stopped as a bullet went thrugh him, who shot him? it wasn't anyone from the crowd, it was behind them, ATPG collasped, dead. Everyone gasped. he was dead.

OOC-

Lynching Results-
AlexanderThePrettyGood - 3
Orb - 1
ByzantineKnight - 1


killer Tally
Murdered - CountArach , Sasaki , SirBoo , Ichigo
Attacked - Sir Boo , Fenring
Lynched - Lord Motep , Stig , AlexanderThePrettyGood

people alive
Sasaki Kojiro
Stig
CountArach
AndrestheCunning
Lord Motep of kendermore
Orb
Ichigo
pevergeen
Fenring
Sir Boo
Alexander the pretty good
Byzantine knight
people left=5


Night 5 has Begun!

[Andres]

We may have got one already?

Does it mean Stig was an assassin? Or did he mean Alexander?



I'm confused

[Kralizec]

Sorry for not posting in a while, people. I've been rather busy in real life, and in addition my own game is eating up quite some time...

[Warluster]

The Final Night
The town was quiet, no noise, people were asleep, except for Orb and Byzantine Knight, they were wide awake, planning there next kills.
"Who next?" asked Orb,
"I am going after pevergreen" said Byzantine Knight,
"then i will go after AndresTheCunning" said orb, and there plans were made. They had nearly won over the town. ByzantineKnight was the first to strike, he snuck over th pevergreens house and waited outside, then started banging on the windows, pevergreen kept on sleeping, so BK threw in an torch, and the house caught on fire, and pevergreen burnt to death.

While Fenring came to help pevrgreen, AndresTheCunning was outside,
AndresTheCunning was running in the hills at four in the morning. At least he could get some exercise and at the same time see an assailant coming.

He was out in the middle of nowhere

"I knew you'd be here, Andres."
He lashed around, to see a tall man behind him rising from a pile of stones. He'd thought it was a cairn. Andres drew his sword, the man remained steady, powerful, carrying only a shield in his left hand, a ceremonial, heavy-handled gold-and-silver sword in a jewelled scabbard at his hip.

"Andres, everything you hear, religion, ethics, justice, practicality is a lie. There is only style."

The shield came around, a topaz-and-ruby blur. Andres stepped backwards and struck out, but everything was over. The man had twisted effortlessly under his blade and drawn the ornamental blade. Andres turned, but the killer had wrapped his foot around Andres' ankle. Andres crashed against the stone and the killer drove his gold-and-silver style into Andres' heart.

While Fenring was trying to help pevergreen, BK and Orb snuch up behind Fenring and pointed a gun to his head.
"We've got the town!" said BK,
"We should call in the French army at once to come in, and take Fenring slave" said Orb, the village was now taken over!

OOC-

MAFIA VICTORY!

Sasaki Kojiro- Normal Townie, killed off by BK

Stig- He was the Master Assasin, baisclly the Don

CountArach- Normal Townie, Killed by Orb

AndrestheCunning- Normal Towie, Killed by Orb

Lord Motep of kendermore- Normal Townie, killed by BK

Orb- He was an siletno, an mafia

Ichigo-Normal Townie, killed by Orb

pevergeen- Normal Townie, killed by BK

Fenring-Normal Townie, taken Slave by Orb and BK

Sir Boo- He was the healer, and protected people every night, he protected BK the first night, and Fenring the next, then killed by Orb

Alexander the pretty good- He was the spy(Detective) and found Stig guilty, but was killed the night after

Byzantine knight- he was mafia!
people left=3, mafia win!


Good Game guys, enjoyed hosting for ya's, I hosted my first mafia game! Whoa!

[ByzantineKnight]

Yay! Finally I win one, lol

[Andres]

Congratulations BK and Orb

Thank you for hosting this one Warluster

And sorry for not believing you Alexander

I'm becoming paranoia. Sasaki with his fake pm's in CDTC has something to do with that, I think

[pevergreen]

GG all.

I could have become more involved if i wasnt a replacement.

More Mafia games! *runs off to other threads*

[Sir Boo]

I knew it wow im reely getting to be a good detective. i said from start that Byzantine was mafia and then again i said Stig was. Although i was unaware of orb he played the game very well

[Orb]

Loved writing my kills up. I think I'll do a story based on my 'ubermensch' character after I've finished the Yom Kippur one.

Anyhow, good attempts, townies, the game was a little pro-us.

Thoughts on improvement for next time:

1) Stress the situation and the difference a little more. The muskets + pistols just felt like another mafia game.
2) Emphasise the plotline a little more, too.

Thoughts for the townies:
Be more careful when lynching. Particularly point out unexpected results of 'logic' (my 'number crunching based on having only 1 mafia, for example)
Avoid 'promising' to do something, like lynching ATPG. Suspect people who attempt to bind you to such things.


This is the fourth time as Mafia/Serial killer that I've won.

(The others were as 'The Thing', where I basically removed active players before using my voice to get lurkers lynched instead, Sasaki's first multi-role mafia, where Sigurd brilliantly finished the game after my death and Capo di tutti capi)

Hints for Mafia:
Be careful, try not to post too much unless you're forced to, make a few posts, all of which seem helpful or add to discussion.
Take out people with cold logic. Don't actually factor in whether they're voting for you or not unless you're fairly desperate.
Play the numbers, never reveal, see if you can detect the doctor and detective early and then assassinate them.

[Stig]

gg all, tbh I think the town lost because I was a don, I didn't have any kills, I couldn't do anything at all (apart from directing kills). Alex spotted me as mafia, as I was one, the problem was that killing didn't stop. If Alex investigated Byzantine Knight instead of me the town would most likely have won as Alex wouldn't be lynched.

[Alexander the Pretty Good]

I was an idiot. Sorry town, I should've investigated a few more or something.

3 mafia for 12 people though?

An instructional short mafia though. Good game, guys!

[Orb]

I was an idiot. Sorry town, I should've investigated a few more or something.

3 mafia for 12 people though?

An instructional short mafia though. Good game, guys!

It's hard, but not unwinnable. You picked out two of the suspects, though I think I largely avoided notice.

Warluster warned us that two deaths was a loss, so in other circumastances you'd have been victorious.

[Sir Boo]

Im actually quite happy with my self for spotting 2 Mafiosos yet i shouldnt have aproached the stig via a pm although is till didnt give my role away....

Can i just ask if anybody got my little give away to the townies in my first NOTE write up?